An Indian court sentenced four men to death Friday for the rape and murder of a 23-year-old woman in New Delhi, an attack that appalled the South Asian nation.

Announcing the sentence, Judge Yogesh Khanna said the crime "shocked the collective conscience" of India and fell into the "rarest of rare category" that deserves capital punishment.

"In these times when crimes against women are on the rise, the court cannot turn a blind eye to this gruesome act," he said.

One of the convicted men, Vinay Sharma, broke down in tears and cried loudly as the judge spoke.
Prosecutors had asked for the death penalty for the men, citing the "extreme brutality" of the attack,
which took place on a moving bus in December. They had also argued the court needed to send a message to Indian society with its judgment.

(read the rest of the article here)

Is the death sentence appropriate in this case? Anyone who's normally against capital punishment ready to make an exception for cases like this?

Views: 538

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion


The men are innocent - its the womens fault.

Because If there were no women there would be no rape.




Yep - I'm kidding Belle

But Im sure its logical somewhere in New Delhi

I think one of the societal norms under which the Constitution was written needs to get with the times. The standard of "Cruel and Unusual Punishment" needs updating in light of the increasing barbarity of so many criminals and their crimes. If the perps don't consider their vile actions to be sufficiently "cruel" to deter them and/or if the frequency of such barbarous acts in our society makes them less "unusual", then the punishment for this barbarism should be adjusted as well. 

A cruel and barbarous punishment to fit a cruel and barbarous crime. A piranha tank, perhaps.

One of the convicted men, Vinay Sharma, broke down in tears and cried loudly as the judge spoke.

Pieces of shit.

Anyway. In a modern society you might wanna treat a case like this differently. But this is India we're talking about so this is at least a step in the right direction since it's an improvement over doing absolutely nothing about women being abused.


I like seeing men get angry about it too Belle.

Its a feeling of protection.

Sure. Dead is dead. But it would be nice to see a little more in the way of both deterrent and revenge.

I didn't say, "feed them live, balls first, to a pack of hungry pigs". I would never suggest such uncivilized punishment.

Have they caught the slime ball who shot Malala Yousafzai?

Pieces of shit, indeed.

My only hesitation about supporting the death penalty for forcible rape is that I suspect a lot of rape victims would end up strangled right afterwards (as they are witnesses to a capital crime).  It is emotionally satisfying to think about making it a capital crime, but would simply result in lots more dead women.

I do think that having them die from lead poisoning on the scene at the hands of their intended victim would be appropriate; I'd love to see many more women armed.  (That's not going to happen in India though.)  Disparity in physical strength?  Two to three pounds of steel will fix that.

Women are less likely to use lethal force than men, I fear. Just a psychological difference between the sexes. She may regard using a gun as Plan B, by which time it's probably too late.

I would say it depends heavily on the individual woman.  As such, I certainly wouldn't want to deny them the option.  If they deny it to themselves, that's a different matter.

In the United States more and more women are showing an interest in being able to defend themselves, and I think this is a wholly positive development.

Life in solitary confinement is the worst punishment imaginable for those who commit the worst crimes imaginable.

Do you really think that a convicted murderer would typically say "I'd rather you just killed me" if offered the option of solitary confinement?

Don't make me laugh. This sort of argument has never rung true to me.


© 2022   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service