"The reason I got involved in public service, by and large, if I had to credit one thinker, one person, it would be Ayn Rand ." That's freshly minted GOP vic...
Do you guys think that Ayn Rand (sorry for those who like her novels, but she was bananas), is giving us Atheist a bad reputation?
Absolutly Yes! There have been many athiest and agnostics throughout history and in modern
times who have dedicated their lives to helping people and in many instances given their lives for
others. You have only to look at athiest firefighters, athiest police officers, and athiest in foxholes!
I read much of Ann Rand in HS, and at-the-time felt some traction with her due to my slow extrication from my catholic upbringing. Sadly I also felt that something was dearly/clearly missing.
Raising the ego to the level of 'a cult of the self', seemed very wrong. We are clearly in a culture of 'others', some of which I love, have respect for, have offered me aide or help, and examples of how to live and NOT live!
I have known people that seem to have little to offer intellectually, but are good souls, and can be heartfelt company. Measuring human value via an abstract human contrived metric such as 'money' seems more like another mal-formed metaphysical commitment.
Pretending that ones ego is self contained or heroic, at the expence of others, seems more like a betrayl of our social and/or cultural connections. While I might accept Rand's position on creativity, I see it as a part of my cultural responsibility, not only in service to my own self interest.
Ryan's point "keep it on message, 'Obama Bad', and off of us". The flustering that seem obvious indicates the 'absence' of a plan to save Medicare or 'Obama Care'.
I don't think Ayn Rand gives atheist a bad name because atheism is not some kind of organization. Of any stretch of the word. Now I agree that she was a fucking sociopath, that believed altruism was evil (yeah helping people for the sake of helping them is evil, fucking nut). But I believe by agreeing that she gives atheist a bad name is only furthering the misunderstanding of what atheism is. She was a lone lunatic, she is not atheism.
I'm an Ayn Rand fan, so this election is going to suck for me.
I think that her economic policies are outdated and are too ideological to work. Unfortunately that is what draws the most criticism, as that is what is most often put out into the public sphere. I'm willing to have a conversation about her moral philosophy, Objectivism, with anyone interested, as I've read the majority of her material (not just her novels, but her essay collections as well) provided that we agree to leave the economics out of it. Again, if you're skimming, read me loud and clear now: I DO NOT AGREE WITH HER ECONOMIC THEORIES.
As far as giving atheists a bad name, I think you already know my answer. No. She doesn't. Rational selfishness is a great base of morality, and is often misunderstood.
That being said, I think that Obama should 100% go after Ryan for his endorsement of Rand. I understand the game. He should play that ideologue 1% card all the way to re-election.
Atheists who want to short-circuit the Romney/Ryan ticket should go about claiming Ryan's atheism-based principles.
You people might want to educate yourself on what her points were before you actually attack her based on them, as it's clear that the majority here missed them. Reading comprehension is a skill you can practice, you know.
Altruism has nothing to do with a 15 trillion dollar debt. Neither candidate will be interested in discussing strategies or policies to actually fix our overspending mania.
Join Think Atheist
Welcome toThink Atheist
Get Started Nowor Sign In
Or sign in with:
Started by Kirk LeFou in Small Talk 3 hours ago.
Started by Davis Goodman in Small Talk 9 hours ago.
Started by Ole Fredrik Skjegstad in The Bible, The Koran, and other scripture. Last reply by TJ 10 hours ago.
Started by JadeBlackOlive in Small Talk. Last reply by TJ 11 hours ago.
Started by TJ in Philosophy. Last reply by TJ on Sunday.
Sunday School July 24th 2016
Sunday School July 17th 2016
Sunday School July 10th 2016
Posted by Davis Goodman on July 26, 2016 at 8:20pm
Posted by navid on July 26, 2016 at 10:00am
Computer Help Forums
© 2016 Created by umar.
Report an Issue |
Terms of Service
Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator.