I asked Davide Robertson "Why you find deism more compelling than atheism?"
This was his response. What is your opinion on his reasons for finding deism more compelling?
He is wrong from the very start. Atheism is not “believing in nothing”. It is a disbelief in the existences of any god. He does not know the meaning of the word. Then he argues from ignorance about the “first cause” and plays the god card. Why does the first cause have to be god? He talks a lot without saying anything. I suspect the book he is trying to promote is much the same.
He then talks about deists growing spiritually which is also saying nothing. He talks about “new information” but does not say what it is. Then he prattles on about how deism is growing rapidly as if we should take that for granted. It is not.
He claims that deism is about intellectual growth, not just spiritual?? That is what Dan Dennett would call a “deepity” – saying something that sounds profound but is facile when given a second thought.
He states that deists (when contrasted with atheists) are constantly looking for new information on the environment, the world, the Universe etc. Yeah, we atheists have stopped asking questions.
He is as he says himself “boring”. He is intellectually dull. He has no information to offer. He says deists enjoy “intellectual stimulation” and says science is usually boring or scary??
He really has nothing compelling to offer and if he has he cannot articulate it. If he thinks he has answered the question, he has not. He is a poor copy of WL Craig.
BTW - good to see you Keith. I haven't changed much, have I? :-)
Thanks Reg, you haven't changed at all haha. Yeah you make some very good points there about David. However I wouldn't go as far as to say he's like William Craig. He's a lot more willing to listen than Craig at least. But I have to admit he hasn't really clarified his reasons for accepting the God of deism. Which sort of leads me back to agnosticism and I'm pretty content with that.
He addressed that in a previous video. I'll share it here if you want to check it out. I'm not really sure if you could really say he answered the issue very clearly. But it was "addressed" in some regard.
I would still say that WL Craig is streets ahead. Here is a good debate with WLC and Hitchens.
OK, watched both above vids, and, well, he's as intellectually blind as a bat.
He can't define what he believes, when making a vid to define what he believes....unless what he believes is essentially that things are complicated, and god is possibly a system rather than a being.
If he pursued that line of reasoning, he'd notice that he's describing nature and the natural world, etc....not a being.
If he'd notice that he automatically dissed the "revealed religions'" because they were in conflict with his worldview, and, in the next breath, said that atheists were closed minded to HIS version of religion, it would allow some perspective for him.
He goes on, and on, and on, about learning and gaining new information...but, always requires that information to point to the existence of god, as a given, accusing those who did the same and came to a different conclusion as close minded and rejecting knowledge.
So, he rambles on about learning, implies that only deists do it, or do it right, and, like all religions, essentially says his is right and the others are wrong...but has no proof or evidence to support his claims even against revealed religions let alone atheism.
It doesn't help that he stereotypes everyone not in his group, assigns them characteristics, and then says why the characteristics he used to define the other groups proves that deism is better, etc.
He essentially doesn't see that his religion is no better than other religions.
If all his study cannot illustrate the truth, its not a search for truth, but simply an effort to reach a predetermined conclusion by cherry picking the data.
Yes TJ I think you may have a point there. There is indeed a sheer lack of clarity from Robertson. Which is a shame because he seems to have done quite a bit of research. Maybe he just finds it difficult finding the right key points to communicate his information with more clarity. Either way he has not really presented enough evidence or indeed reason to present a truly compelling case.
Man I'm so glad this website is still here haha.
His research, though, is not really being performed in a productive manner.
He finds it difficult to express what he is trying to convey, because he has run into conflicting information, and struggles to ignore the parts in conflict with his worldview.
He conflates seeking knowledge with his religion...but, as with all religions, he doesn't seem to realize that he is starting with the given of there being a deity.
If he would drop his preconceived given, and TRULY investigate as diligently as he currently thinks he is, he would, potentially, come to drop his preconceived notion....and discover what he is looking for (Truth).
He CANNOT clearly present a compelling case, because he has not found a compelling case. Its not a lack of clarity, its the lack of a compelling case.
He resorts to dancing around the case he WANTS TO present, as compelling, albeit talks instead about learning and other things that are not relevant to his case...as if they were.
If his "religion" did not have a supernatural element to it...perhaps, being the worship of science and knowledge, etc...something that at least exists, THEN all his current babble could at least be considered somewhat more relevant.
Otherwise, its just a lot of wasted air.
Join Think Atheist
Welcome toThink Atheist
Get Started Nowor Sign In
Or sign in with:
Started by rationalrevolution in The Bible, The Koran, and other scripture Aug 11.
Started by D L in Small Talk. Last reply by D L Feb 22.
Started by Gregg RThomas in Small Talk Oct 27, 2017.
Started by Violetta Fay in Small Talk. Last reply by Tom Ozminkowski Jun 24.
Started by Jimmy in Neuroscience, Cognitive Science, Psychology Sep 25, 2017.
Sunday School May 28th 2017
Sunday School May 21st 2017
Sunday School May 14th 2017
Posted by Muhammad ali on August 5, 2017 at 9:27am
Posted by Brad Snowder on July 9, 2017 at 1:08am
© 2018 Created by Rebel.
Report an Issue |
Terms of Service
Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator.