Why Religion Can Be Criticized Not Only By The Religious

It is sometimes argued that only the religious could really comprehend religion and that, therefore, the irreligious ought to abstain from criticizing religion or religious beliefs. In other words, a peculiar worldview can only be fully understood from within and should thus be criticized only from within.

This argument can easily be refuted by a reductio ad absurdum. If it were true that peculiar worldviews could only be comprehended by those supporting them, respectively, and ought to be criticized only by them, then it would follow that fascism could only be fully understood by fascists, that communism could only be fully understood by communists, that conservatism could only be fully understood by conservatives, and so forth, so that everyone who is not a fascist ought to abstain from criticizing fascism, everyone who is not a communist ought to abstain from criticizing communism, everyone who is not a conservative ought to abstain from criticizing conservatism, and so on – which would be absurd (I call this the ‘first-person knowledge requirement fallacy’); quod erat demonstrandum.

Views: 23

Tags: absurd, absurdum, ad, argue, argument, comprehend, comprehension, criticism, criticize, philosophical, More…philosophy, reductio, refutation, refute, religion, worldview

Comment

You need to be a member of Think Atheist to add comments!

Join Think Atheist

Forum

Nude atheist group

Started by Raymond in Society. Last reply by Raymond 23 hours ago. 4 Replies

Socratic Method

Started by Michael in Ethics & Morals. Last reply by Davis Goodman 21 minutes ago. 4 Replies

Babies Are Not Born Atheists

Started by Ed in Small Talk. Last reply by matt.clerke 6 hours ago. 22 Replies

Gideons International

Started by Ed in Small Talk. Last reply by Gallup's Mirror 4 hours ago. 6 Replies

Events

Blog Posts

Non-traditional Marraige

Posted by Andy Hoke on May 25, 2015 at 10:57pm 0 Comments

YES

Posted by Reg The Fronkey Farmer on May 23, 2015 at 5:00pm 13 Comments

Services we love!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service