I recently struck up a facebook "conversation" with a family member.  I shared a link to an article talking about the catholic leaders blatant use of the church to spread their political agenda.  I commented claiming that the members of the church need to start questioning this practice and, if not, the church should be taxed since it is clearly not following the law. 

He stated that if the IRS took them to court, the court would uphold its right to free speech "for fear of improperly advocating for one Church over another and also in light of the recent Supreme Court case on free speech and money in politics, under the right of Churches to speak broadly on political issues like other non-profits."

I know that the IRS law is clear in black and white when it comes to tax exempt organizations, but does he have a point?

Is there really no clear answer because of these new laws, combined with the Internal revenue services inability, or unwillingness to actually enforce its existing laws?


Views: 102

Comment by Dr.Grixis on October 10, 2012 at 8:26am

Freedom of speech in itself is fine, it's one of the most important principles in any democratic society. However tax exempt organizations profit from the taxes that we all pay, by operating in the framework of society that has been build with society's money.

Thus, if an organization has the privilege of not having to pay taxes, in return they have to accept that they are supported by the whole of the political spectrum and should therefor not pertain in specifics in regards to political affairs. 

The right to freedom of speech is something that any church can obtain by letting go of their tax exempt status. Say like the rest of us, pay like the rest of us.

Comment by Unseen on October 10, 2012 at 9:15am

There is a broad church-based act of defiance in the works where thousands of church pastors will make a specific recommendation (for Romney more often than not). They'll be daring the IRS to come after them so that they can get a case before the Supreme Court to decide which right takes precedence. Read about it here


You need to be a member of Think Atheist to add comments!

Join Think Atheist

© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service