I'm starting to doubt Republicans and Libertarians read newspapers..

One of my favorite methods of auto-flagellation is to follow the US political system. From this act I'm starting to gather that there appears to be a run-up to an election and one of the themes is that the US government needs to be cut in size and more economic power handed over to the individual states. The ones pushing the hardest for this is the Republican party in general and the Libertarians in particular. Apparently, cutting the size of government is the panacea to all social issues.

I don't immediately buy this argument, in fact, I actually have sincere doubts about its validity. The US is a large federal state made up of many cooperating member states. When signing up to be part of the US, states agree to a number of things, i.e. to share a common external border, allow free flow of goods, services, capital, and people, and accept the dollar as the currency. 

Within such a construct, what can happen if the role of the federal government is reduced? Well, it's difficult to say, economics isn't really an experimental science. However, it is a comparable science. So, let me think. Is there anything which has some of the characteristics of the US..? Hmm.. It's a tricky question..

Oh wait! There's this thing called the EU! It's made up of many member states, has a shared external border, a customs union, allows for the four freedoms, and it even has its own currency. In addition, the EU budget is tiny , only around 5% the size of the US federal budget; Surely, this must be a true Libertarian paradise. It's a good thing that one of the lessons learned the hard way these days is that having a monetary union without a fiscal union does not cause major economic headaches.

Oh wait.. That's exactly the lesson being learnt these days. The EU is pushing hard for closer fiscal cooperation. It's been found to be near impossible to have a monetary union - a single currency and a single central bank - without also having extremely strong and complex regulation of member states fiscal responsibilities or a larger common budget.


So seeing as this story should have been reported in the press (even in the US) I'm really starting to doubt that Republicans and Libertarians read newspapers.. Or perhaps, just like many Europeans want a United States of Europe, perhaps these people want an American Union. :p

Views: 237

Comment by Ed on October 2, 2011 at 10:56am

@ Arcus   


"So those in favor of death penalty can be terminated since they also fulfill your premise?"

Committing a crime beforehand would be a necessity I'm thinkin'....


"Why the fascination with punishment? Why not rehabilitate and make the productive members of society?"

Punishment does not fascinate me. I prefer the word justice. This may burst your bubble but I cannot say emphatically enough that rehabilitation is a pipe dream in regard to many convicted felons. I worked in a prison environment for years and dealt with individuals, not all BTW, who had absolutely no desire to change their ways. Some would go so far as to say they would commit the crime over again if given the opportunity. Unfortunately there are individuals in our society who have a perverted sense of reality and are incapable of experiencing remorse after committing a crime against another. Adopting a passive attitude towards them will be viewed by the unrepentent convict as an opportunity to take advantage of your kindness. They will shower you with the most lovely of smiles while secretly holding that shank. It sucks but it's called reality.  


As to the death penalty, you cannot deny one thing: A convicted murderer who is executed will not kill again. That problem is solved once and for all.




You need to be a member of Think Atheist to add comments!

Join Think Atheist

© 2019   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service