I don't know if anyone else engages the Christian propagandists on YouTube, but I've found it to be terribly entertaining - and great debating practice to boot. This is a conversation that started on some Christian chick's (I was invited) channel where I and a few other Atheists were pummeling her logic, when this guy invited me to come to his channel for a real Christian education - I mean, he really baited me with the idea of evidence for god that I was probably unfamiliar with - I had to see that.
Anyway, I was unable to watch his complete educational series - they were totally retarded and mind-numbing but since I was there, I decided it might be fun to poke the bear with a stick. The following exchange is my poking, along with a few others that decided to jump in.

daveisnothome (1 day ago)
I am curious ETA - what is your religion if not Christian? If you are one of the Christian denominations then where do you separate yourself from the 1500 year Catholic-only history of the Christian church? Is the Christian church new? Do you incorporate the Jewish history into your religion as well? What is your impression of the council of Jerusalem in 65 CE?

EducatingTheAtheists (1 day ago)
I am a person adopted out of the group that God regrets making and into the group that he doesn't.
The word "catholic" simply means "universal". Are you refering to the Roman Catholic religion?
Jesus was a Jew along with His twelve apostles and the first several thousand believers. Salvation came through the Jews.
Are you refering to the Council at Jerusalem where Peter addressed the heresy of the Judaisers when the gospel of Grace was solidified among the gentiles? I'm very familiar with it.

daveisnothome (1 day ago)
Awkward for God that he has to repent again - for your sake I hope he got it right this time and doesn't have to go find some more chosen people.
Must have been a different council, the one I'm referring to decided whether to accept Gentiles into the all-Jew Apostolic church and if these new converts should have to follow Mosaic Law, including circumcision, just like the Jewish Christians did. I personally think this is when the Christian church petered out and became a state religion.

EducatingTheAtheists (1 day ago)
His regret dates back to the fall. His plan of salvation has always been the same.

The council of Jerusalem account is found in Acts15 and deals with the Law of Moses and the Gentiles as well as the Jews. Please read it for yourself. My first book , "Fallen From Grace" goes into great detail concerning this event.

daveisnothome (1 day ago)
I'm not visiting your channel for an education, I've had that in spades. I'm only curious why you think you have information that hasn't been out there for centuries. If anything, you might consider calling your channel educating the christian because that's where the deficit is.
As far as you using any biblical account as a historical reference, that's not much better than guesswork if you're the scholar you claim to be then that's obvious though.
Peace

EducatingTheAtheists (1 day ago)
As long as you understand the difference between education and indoctrination and that any attempt to figure this out at all is tacit acceptance of deism in the very least due to the fact that logic is transcendental.

daveisnothome (1 day ago)
Your logic and reasoning are "tacit" to a hamster chasing his tail on a running wheel until he dies. The only thing I'm trying to figure out on any believer's channel is why anyone would accept the idea of a god in lieu of accepting reality. So far I've concluded that man is #1-too lazy to look, #2-Afraid of dying and the unknown, and #3-He has inherited Christian ideals from his parents, community, and culture - and again he's too lazy and afraid to step away and entertain new ideas.

creationutcase (1 day ago)
You missed #4 Mental illness

daveisnothome (1 day ago)
It would be great if you stopped handing out judgment and labels and instead humbly share the knowledge you claim to have found. You are not that fascinating or enlightened no matter what your fans might tell you. You invited me here and I'm trying to be courteous while I listen to you - believe me it's not easy.

EducatingTheAtheists (1 day ago)
Why have you not addressed the issue of the transcendental evidence for God... like logic for example.
I used to be an atheist. I used to believe that there was no evidence for God. I used to ignore the "everything" that goes on outside the natural world. I used to hold to the "Big Bang" theory while ignoring its cause. I use to believe that humans evolved from primates in spite of the complete lack of transitional evidence. You say "entertain new ideas". I say your ideas are old hat to me.

creationutcase (1 day ago)
Your understanding of evolutionary theory is almost child like.
Are you aware that even if we had no fossils to look at we would still know that evolution was fact just from the molecular evidence?
Name one fact regarding species diversity that your creation story explains better than evolutionary theory does.
ERVs, nested heirachies, atavisms, the fossil record, vestigial structures, gene sequencing, embryology, morphology, come on, just one fact.

daveisnothome (20 hours ago)
TAG uses circular reasoning and assumes from the start what it is going to conclude. It does not fulfill the pre-reqs for an argument of proof - it's based on assumptions. What are you premises? Have you proven those premises before you made your Yahweh conclusion? Could you plug Allah into that premise? Zeus?

daveisnothome (20 hours ago)
And, it is incorrect to establish that premise of a logical moral god based on Yahweh as Yahweh has repeatedly proven his sadistic nature and faulty logic - thus destroying Kant's theory that God's nature is the source of logic and morals.

EducatingTheAtheists (11 hours ago)
I don't know what "Kant"s theory is on logic and morals. Morality is subjective. Dan Barker (well known atheist apologist) put forth a theory wherein rape would be moral so yes, it is difficult to argue for the objectivity of morality apart from picking one deity over another. Religious fanatics will justify all kinds of horrors for their "god". I subscribe to no religion at all.
Logic, however, is transcendental and mocks naturalism to its face... according to Isaac Newton at least.

creationutcase (4 hours ago)
answer my question, if you can, if not you shouldn't be so dismissive of evolutionary theory.
Name one fact regarding species diversity that your creation story explains better than evolutionary theory does.
ERVs, nested heirachies, atavisms, the fossil record, vestigial structures, gene sequencing, embryology, morphology, come on, just one fact.

EducatingTheAtheists (11 hours ago)
Did i mention TAG anywhere in my comments? I asked you about logic. That's all. It applies to everyone. It does not rely on a person's ability to understand it and it is not a naturally ocurring substance. It is omnipresent in the universe and it is transcendental.
I do not argue in favor of any deity. I argue againsy the illogical philosophy of naturalism. Allah and Zeus are different discussions. You cannot know the truth about any god as long as your trapped in the delusion of naturalism.

creationutcase (4 hours ago)
"Why have you not addressed the issue of the transcendental evidence for God... like logic for example."
That IS TAG numbnuts.

EducatingTheAtheists (3 hours ago)
I know what TAG is.
Calling me belittling names gets you nothing. I defer to ppsimmons for science.

dogofthegaps (2 hours ago)
That's right, just keep blocking people because they disagree with you, asshole
ppsimmons and science? lol, he has as much scientific knowledge as the people who wrote your stupid little holy book, what joke you are.

dogofthegaps (1 hour ago)
If you can't answer the most basic of challenges re evolution vs creation you have no business denying that evolution happens, ever.

Stick to what you know and leave the science to rational people.

PkmnNameRater (52 minutes ago)
Please explain to me how it makes sense that someone just appeared in the middle of nowhere and created the world. Science is something that actually has proof, unlike believing that a fairy created everything today.

Views: 3

Tags: Kant, TAG, Transcendental Logic, christian logic

Comment by Reggie on August 12, 2009 at 11:49pm
He's a chosen one. Those are the scariest. Way to call him out on his (unwitting?) use of TAG.
Comment by Misty: Baytheist Living! on August 13, 2009 at 6:08am
~facepalm~
That's why I avoid that place.
At least here I can argue with non-delusional people..
Comment by Chris on August 13, 2009 at 10:48am
So who's the deist? Certainly not this guy. Deists do not believe that "God" regrets making one group and not another (what an asshole Father God that would be) nor do they believe that "God" has a plan of salvation. This guy's Christian through and through.

He mentioned something about the "fact" that trying to figure any of this out makes us all "deists" at least because logic is trancendental. (listened to an atheist talk show host and a Christian apologist on YouTube argue this point in circles until I wanted to scream) Are we the deists then?
Comment by Reggie on August 13, 2009 at 1:24pm
He mentioned something about the "fact" that trying to figure any of this out makes us all "deists" at least because logic is trancendental. (listened to an atheist talk show host and a Christian apologist on YouTube argue this point in circles until I wanted to scream) Are we the deists then?

Dillahunty and Slick?
Comment by CJoe on August 13, 2009 at 1:56pm
Ha! I'm so proud you're mah dad... I see you've been reading your critical thinking/argumentation books? Well played.
Comment by davesnothome on August 13, 2009 at 2:04pm
@ Misty - good point, however most of us agree here and I enjoy some energetic resistance. Also, my family believes this stuff and I like to get into their heads without pissing them off - he's their proxy.

@ Chris - ironic right? their logic is mind-numbing.
Comment by Reggie on August 13, 2009 at 2:29pm
He's your dad? How very cool!
Comment by Morgan Matthew on August 13, 2009 at 2:45pm

Comment by Chris on August 13, 2009 at 4:18pm
@Reggie, Yep, that was them. Interesting, but neither of them really paid any attention to what the other was saying, so they just went in circles. Nerve-wracking.
Comment by CJoe on August 13, 2009 at 4:49pm
Yeah, he's my dad. I had to throw that in there... :D

Comment

You need to be a member of Think Atheist to add comments!

Join Think Atheist

Blog Posts

Life Condensed

Posted by Cato Rigas on October 19, 2014 at 8:30pm 1 Comment

Cool Vehicle Inspection!

Posted by Ed on October 18, 2014 at 9:03am 2 Comments

Services we love!

We are in love with our Amazon

Book Store!

Gadget Nerd? Check out Giz Gad!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

In need a of a professional web site? Check out the good folks at Clear Space Media

© 2014   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service