• Male
  • Portland, OR
  • United States
Share on Facebook

Unseen's Friends

  • TJ
  • Derek Cantrell
  • archaeopteryx
  • Mai
  • Virgil
  • Brandon Bissell
  • Belle Rose
  • Derp McChuckles
  • Jesse Selasi
  • Omnipotent Feces
  • Andy Hoke
  • EMil Wentzel
  • Justin
  • Royal red
  • David Smith

Unseen's Discussions

What does "earn" mean to you?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Unseen 11 hours ago. 65 Replies

"Liberals just want to take money that isn't theirs and give it to people who didn't earn it" is the sort of thing I've heard from conservatives many times.This often comes up when talking about…Continue

Tags: socialism, redistribution, earnings, wealth

Does Each person possess an inviolability founded on justice...

Started this discussion. Last reply by Simon Paynton Nov 23. 14 Replies

...that even the welfare of society as a whole cannot override? (John Rawls' most famous quote.)If not why not? If so, what would it mean in particular cases?Continue

Tags: individual, justice, Rawls

Anarchism: threat or menace? (Scott Graves, this means you)

Started this discussion. Last reply by Ian Nov 25. 91 Replies

Okay, forgive me the attention-getting headline. Scott Graves has proclaimed himself an anarchist. I went through this phase for about a year when I was in my late teens. Since then, I think I've…Continue

Tags: anarchy, anarchism, anarchist

Paris attack will boost Trump

Started this discussion. Last reply by TJ Nov 17. 8 Replies

The GOP is hard line anyway and a lot of people will look at Donald Trump with his anti-immigration stance and his position that the nation needs firm borders or even a wall, then look at Paris, and…Continue

Tags: Republicans, poll, anti-immigration, immigration, Paris

Gifts Received


Unseen has not received any gifts yet

Give a Gift


Unseen's Page

Latest Activity

Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"My working hypothesis at this point is that the way you use "earning something" is business jargon, and isn't the same thing at all as earning a Congressional Medal of Honor or even a bowling trophy. Both of those carry a certain…"
11 hours ago
Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Back to the top level... What I'm asking is the topic: What does it mean to say something has been "earned." Most words have multiple meanings and nuances, but what does the average person mean by "earnings" and "to…"
12 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"There is nothing to be gained by reducing a complex term to a bare bones minimal definition (especially when the use of the term is highly subjective qualitatively and quantitatively). If I must have a go, earn means getting or deserving the…"
12 hours ago
TJ replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"@Davis - I went out into my yard, of the land I own, and dig a small hole. I put a little fertilizer and the seed in the hole, watered it while packing in fresh soil, and tamped it down to a slight cone shape from the peak down to the edges. Where I…"
15 hours ago
TJ replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"But "earning" is still open as a definition. You have not defined what you mean adequately. I can not answer until I have a feel for what it is you are asking. Davis gave some very good examples of variables that would potentially change…"
15 hours ago
Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Once again, you're wandering away from the question of meaning into practicalities of application and consequences. I'm an ordinary language philosopher. I look at what we mean in everyday life to earn something, to deserve something, and…"
Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"I'm not speaking for theists; I'm speaking for those of us who've engaged in arguments over ethics with theists. If they feel I've distorted their position, let them raise the objection.  Still, how about you? Would you say…"
Davis Goodman replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"It all depends on so many variables its impossible to answer. Was it on your property? Does anyone else nhave a claim to it? Did you personally plant it ormdid you pay someone else to do it. Did you plant many yet only this is fruitful? Did you…"
TJ replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Well said. The problem, again, is human nature. I understand what he is saying, and why, albeit am trying to express that the very nature of human beings is to be opportunistic and efficient. This is why we invent things, improve things, and why,…"
matt.clerke replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Maybe... he does seem to have that psychopathic personality which seems to be so successful in business. I get what you mean by help but I don't understand your point. Are you saying rich people shouldn't pass on their wealth to their…"
Davis Goodman replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Unseen is asking a broader question about what it means to earn something and not whether certain aspects of Western of free market societies are fair. The question is...does our concept of earn result in a just society where the majority of people…"
TJ replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Well, your question is did they earn the wealth. I answered, with the analogy, of if a man who plants an apple seed, earned the apples, 20 years later when the tree bore fruit? IE: He only planted a single seed.  It was not much work. …"
Dr. Bob replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Based on the "theist" comment I assume you're replying to me.  I actually wasn't addressing you at all.  As the quotes indicated, I was responding to TJ.  My response to you is below."
Ian Fraiser replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Guys- I admit I have nothing to add, but this is a great discussion. Thank you and have a great day."
Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
"Theists judge the truth of a proposition based on their speculations over the consequences of believing it. It seems you might be arguing in the same fashion much of the time. You disagree with what you think I'm saying or implying because you…"
Unseen replied to Unseen's discussion 'What does "earn" mean to you?'
" Trump explaining how he started out: "I got a small loan of a million dollars from my father." "

Profile Information

Your Religious Status
About Me:
MA in Philosophy. I call myself an atheistic agnostic. In other words, I'm atheist until someone proves I'm wrong.
Relationship Status
Why are you here?
I followed a link on twitter
The religion you left
Why you left your religion.
Strangely, you don't include the most obvious answer: God doesn't appear to exist, even as a possibility.
How did you hear about Think Atheist?
followed a link I saw on twitter

Unseen's Blog

Scientists are now admitting that nuclear power is greener than other alternatives

Posted on January 8, 2015 at 12:29pm 36 Comments

The full read from which the following quote is taken is here.

Nuclear power is one of the least damaging sources of energy for the environment, and the green movement must accept its expansion if the world is to…


A great number of paradoxes, starting with Scroedinger's cat

Posted on April 18, 2014 at 8:00pm 1 Comment

I'm sorry, but I had to stop listening to this bit at about the fourth paradox due to being out of breath from laughing. How long can you last?

Famous last words. No...really!

Posted on February 6, 2014 at 6:30pm 1 Comment

I found a website where Texas lists every capital execution from 1982 on. One of the more interesting things about it is that it includes any last statements the prisoners made. Interesting reading. Lots of "foxhole converts" among them, I note.

OBAMACARE Is Better Than You Think

Posted on September 24, 2013 at 11:40am 1 Comment

In just one week the main part of Obamacare will begin to kick in. This is the state level exchanges that will allow the uninsured to be covered. Beginning on October 1, people will be able to sign up to get insurance in their state regardless of their health.

Most people signing up on the exchanges will qualify for subsidies based on their income and family size. This means that the cost of insurance will be less than the advertised price.

This is good…


Comment Wall (20 comments)

You need to be a member of Think Atheist to add comments!

Join Think Atheist

At 3:26pm on December 14, 2014, Virgil said…

You and I got off to a bad start and I almost gave up on AT cuz of it.  I'm glad I didn't.  Amazing how much you and I agree on besides views on how jobs are created, the meaning of wealth and what produces it. All of that I believe about those things are from my personal experience in the past 5 years since becoming a civilian. I believe in them more today than ever before but all that is teeny minor crap compared to my core convictions.  The main reason I argued with you about that was the wrong reason to to argue.  I was offended on a personal level by things you said and I gave into that & put my anger ahead of reason. 

Interrogation.  Please point out any errors in you see in my reasoning.... (why ask, you'll do it even if I don't ask hahahaha!)

my last tour 2009 in Afgh I was a E4, a corporal, just one tiny small guy the big picture. When I heard this report was coming out I thought "oh shit!  This is going to get nasty!"  But wait... "nasty" is a relative term. As a war vet, my idea of nasty in regards to what could have been in that report  is waaaaaaaaay different from Joe Civilian's definition of nasty.  In fact my definition of nasty info on EIT would be impossible for him to wrap his head around and not break out in a chicken little dance. 

There's no damned way Feinstein & the others with that report know less about EIT than I do unless the CIA and armed forces have been totally lying to them.  That's just not possible. 

I've read all I can find for details, watched TV for the hot talking points and I have come to the conclusion that whole report just about has to be a psyop to cover ALLLLLLLLL the shit guys like me know and all the shit guys like me don't know.  For me there hasn't been ONE DETAIL in that report that was newsy or nasty.  I really feel what's going on is a well planned magician's trick that starts  off with him saying, "watch me cut off my right hand" to distract everyone IN THE WORLD while they sneak a 60 ton plaid elephant across the stage. 

This isn't a conspiracy theory about some secret plot from the Obama white house.  This is a theory about possibly pulling off a great Intel move to benefit the very people and programs that it's supposed to be making the focus of world wide outrage. 

But wait.  There's more.

There were things in that report that were totally ridiculous and almost funny when you thin about them.  ONLY  dummasses would fall for some of the shit AND the media and none of the "experts" have even tried to point the silly shit out. 

Think. The report says next to no vital intel has been obtained through EIT.  It says most of the intel obtained is lies told under torture.  I don't recall ONE time in my whole 22 months in Afgh when we were told, "get your guns and let's go find some bad guys to shoot." Every time we did anything se went out to specific places looking at specific times, to look for specific people, specific things and act like we were just dumb gyrines who didn't know what we were looking for. One time we did a four hour search on a small 6 house village before "noticing" the exact item we'd been shown satellite images of sitting right in our way the whole time.   Sooooo where did that intel come from?  The pentagon must be using psychics and have consult fortune tellers.  ...........  That's just one example.  One time we were rushed out to set up a  fake road check, told what car to look for, who would be in it and make sure its 4 tires were blown out 1 km before the road block so the occupants would have to get out and walk after all traffic on the road was stopped to prevent them from hitching rides.  When we go the guys back to base there were interesting guys there. After a staged accidental explosion the 3

At 9:06pm on September 19, 2014, Davis Goodman said…

Can't believe we weren't official friends here all this time!!!!

At 3:34am on September 2, 2014, Demetrius Alcala said…

You stole CBS

At 7:51am on August 10, 2014, Brandon Bissell said…

Yeah thanks. I was hoping to talk to you about something so I'll send a message soon.

At 10:30pm on March 25, 2014, Justin said…

ah yes Im new to it, thank u

At 2:58am on March 25, 2014, EMil Wentzel said…

Thanks :)

I'm still feeling my way around, glad to see so many wonderful positive and active voices here :)

At 11:56am on February 7, 2014, Reg The Fronkey Farmer said…

Thanks for the add Unseen. We took long enough lol...

At 2:46pm on August 30, 2013, Beth said…

Nice to meet you too!

At 4:25am on March 3, 2013, Gregg R Thomas said…

You Tyrant You.  LOL

Oh well at least we now have Richard Bohn, I wonder how long he will last. :D

At 10:33pm on March 2, 2013, Gregg R Thomas said…

Nice to be here, your thread got closed.

That's one of my pet peeves about Internet forums, the arbitrary overreaching invisible controlling hand.  But maybe it's just me...I gots me plentys of pets that peeves me. :D 


© 2015   Created by umar.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service