"I didn't mean to make that distinction to contradict you Ward, it's just that this entire thread is a bit irrelevant, inasmuch as there is no hell, no mentally ill person, not even Rick Santorum, could possibly go there, as much as we…"
-
Jeff Lund
- Male
- Huntington Beach, CA
- United States
- Blog Posts
- Discussions (1)
- Events
- Groups
- Photos
- Photo Albums
- Videos
Jeff Lund's Discussions
Do the mentally ill go to hell?
Started this discussion. Last reply by archaeopteryx Mar 19, 2012. 38 Replies 0 Likes
I had a christian tell me last week that according to christian belief, those afflicted with mental illness go to hell. I felt this was seriously out of line and informed the christian of a mental…Continue
Gifts Received
Jeff Lund has not received any gifts yet
Jeff Lund's Page
Latest Activity
Ward Cressin replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Yes. That was why the word 'correct' was in quotes since neither would actually be correct - just accurate according to the local lore."
archaeopteryx replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Ward - I think it would be safer to say that both myths are BS, with the people/culture/locale determining which one was believed?
pax vobiscum,archaeopteryxwww.in-His-own-image.com"
Ward Cressin replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"I had heard that the myth was your soul could be dislodged and come flying out during a sneeze - thus the "Bless you".
Or are both myths "correct" with the people/culture/locale determining which one was believed?"
Ward Cressin replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"That is why I rent my demons. :)"
archaeopteryx replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Don't know where to post this shining tribute to the benefits of religion, so I'll stick it in here:
"
Cristynfaye replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"It's Cristyn, and the stigma exists both in and out of the church. I've been on both sides, I've seen it on both sides. I'm also quite involved in the behavioral sciences, as there is mental illness in my family, and…"
Rob Klaers replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"That was my point, that we as individuals have judged what is right for us.. Now, as for homosexuality, not my thing, but I don't see it as my place to condemn someone for that. "
Stephen Walski replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Im still trying to figure out how you distinguish the diagnosed mentally ill from the rest of the fruitcakes in the church."
Shabaka Tecumseh replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Crist, "stigma?" The church is the asylum. The "stigma" comes in when you are an atheist."
Cristynfaye replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"I think there is still sort of a stigma about being mentally ill in the church. Because when you become a Christian, the Holy Spirit is supposed to free you from all the bonds of whatever is keeping you from a fulfilled life. So when…"
Bobevt replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"I'm mentally ill and I don't being put in the same sentence with these guys.
mentally ill, serial killer, Hitler or (add horrible person here) can NOT go anywhere after death..
I'm not Mad, upset if you want check out my…"
Kelin420 replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"There is NO such a place- so nobody can go there- unless you mean Hell, Grand Cayman, or maybe Hell, Norway. No such a thing or place- so NO they and no-one else can go there... mentally ill, serial killer, Hitler or (add horrible person…"
Tom Sarbeck replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"These days they would definitely be locked away in a mental asylum?
They might run for public office...and be elected!
"
"Well, what is "right" for you may be "wrong" for someone else and vice-versa. For example, homosexuality would be "wrong" or "sinful" for me because I'm naturally heterosexual. On the contrary,…"
Shabaka Tecumseh replied to Jeff Lund's discussion 'Do the mentally ill go to hell?'"Yes in straight jackets."
Profile Information
- Your Religious Status
- Atheist
- About Me:
- I am the father of two and married to a Catholic. I work in a rationale world of science helping people overcome irrational beliefs. I believe belief in any god is irrational and unhealthy to becoming an authentic person.
- Age
- 36-40
- Relationship Status
- Married
- Why are you here?
- I'm looking for support and to support others that feel the pressures of religion on them daily. Oppression occurs at all levels in life and I want to see that religious people stop oppressing others with their beliefs, including me.
- The religion you left
- Catholic
- Why you left your religion.
- It clearly wasn't true. I joined when I married at 27. I left at 29. There was no proof aside from a book that is several thousand years old. God never spoke to me, no signs, nothing. Of course no one could answer the most basic questions, and they still can't. We all know what they are.
- Think Atheist Travel Network Couch Availability - Are you able to host anyone now?
- Maybe
- How did you hear about Think Atheist?
Comment Wall (1 comment)
- At 9:58am on March 14, 2012,
Robert Karp said… Welcome to the Think Atheist community Jeff! Join us in the chat on the bottom right of the screen and feel free to ask questions and get involved as much or as little as you want! Welcome again and make yourself at home!
What's new today
Forum
Is your trust in science based on faith or based on science?
Started by G in Ethics & Morals. Last reply by archaeopteryx 3 minutes ago. 282 Replies 0 Likes
Blog Posts
Deep Sky Zodiac
Posted by Brad Snowder on May 20, 2013 at 11:29am 0 Comments 0 Likes
Events
Services we love
Check out our new mobile/tablet version of Think Atheist! www.ThinkAtheist.com/m
© 2013 Created by Morgan Matthew.
