i would hope people can see past the little things and understand that there's bigger issues.. we can debate the philosophy of multicultarlism or we can see it for what it is.. a coming together of different practises.. some practises can live simultaneously without really imposing itself on the other.. and some need to be abolished..
I'd tend to disagree, Unseen. There are rights, there are countries and cultures that respect them, and cultures and cultures that don't--to varying degrees.
I have a question: How does one beat their wife "with good intentions"?
a couple of examples would be:
to keep his family in "order"
following 4:34 from the quran.. and other hadiths ..
@SteveInCO That is the naive view. It falls apart as soon as someone asks, where do rights come from? (answer: legislation) What makes rights real? (answer: the ability, through naked power, to enforce them).
Just as those who win the war get to write history, those with the guns get to say what's a right and what's not.
@matt.clerke Answer: delusionally.
women's rights did not come about because the women had machine guns or took up arms.. just like our morality has evolved, our laws have changed, ~cultures, traditions, especially those encouraged by religion, need to be looked at
there are basic freedoms that everyone should have.. and if a culture tramples on those basic rights, then it's those particular practises that should be examined.
@Nessrriinn "women's rights did not come about because the women had machine guns or took up arms"
But if they don't have rights, they are prisoners of the most powerful side: the side that wants them to have them or the side that doesn't. The power aspect of rights is unavoidable.
"just like our morality has evolved, our laws have changed, ~cultures, traditions, especially those encouraged by religion, need to be looked at"
They can evolve all they want, but without some way of enforcing rights, there are no rights, and to enforce rights legitimately, you need a framework based on legislation.
"there are basic freedoms that everyone should have.. and if a culture tramples on those basic rights, then it's those particular practises that should be examined"
Without a God to say something is right because he/she says so, and will damn anyone who disobeys, you are stuck with what people are willing to do in a framework of laws. Laws create rights, and that is why I keep going back to legislation. If that government has the power and the will to enforce your rights, then you have rights in a practical sense.
As for "basic freedoms that everyone should have," those are beliefs which will vary from place to place and culture to culture. Just beliefs. No more. All you have to do is look around to see how women are treated, or expect to be treated, all around the world to see that this is true.
There are no human rights.
Unseen, it's not the naive view. It's just that no one has ever bothered to explain to you the objective basis of rights. Unfortunately, I can't quite manage to do it without a huge long essay (which is on my to-do list).
Frankly the notion that rights are arbitrary and purely whateverthehell the local government wants them to be is scary to me. They exist, a government either recognizes them or it doesn't. That's pretty much what the Declaration of Independence says, and I agree with that. Your stance leaves us with no philosophical underpinning for any sort of freedom. I would be very worried if you were in political power.
That's an easy cop out. I have taught philosophy and the STUDENTS in a good philosophy class would be wiping the floor with the idea of objective rights apart from a deity.
Sure, arbitrary rights are scary, but so is living without a god to tell you what he wants you to do.
You refer to the Declaration of Independence (a document which refers to God) and also, I would assume (though you didn't say so) to The Constitution (another document with references to God). God aside, notice that both are LEGISLATION.
Join Think Atheist
Welcome toThink Atheist
Get Started Nowor Sign In
Or sign in with:
Started by Davis Goodman in Small Talk. Last reply by Pope Beanie 49 minutes ago.
Started by Belle Rose in Politics. Last reply by Noel 7 hours ago.
Started by Belle Rose in Society. Last reply by Belle Rose yesterday.
Started by mobojo23 in Small Talk. Last reply by TJ yesterday.
Started by Unseen in Physics, Astronomy, Cosmology. Last reply by Unseen 15 hours ago.
Sunday School June 19th 2016
Sunday School June 12th 2016
Sunday School June 5th 2016
Posted by innerspaceboy on June 23, 2016 at 10:00pm
Posted by innerspaceboy on June 23, 2016 at 7:32pm
Computer Help Forums
© 2016 Created by umar.
Report an Issue |
Terms of Service
Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator.