Belle Rose replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"Hahaha! lmfao! Wow you must be psychic! You totally KNOW me! It's like we were meant to be! Hahahaha!!!! I don't like the term "materialist." I am the LEAST materialistic person…"
3 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"Seems like you are focusing on a subjective description being correct regardless of the intention or human error. That's closer to materialist with a tiny touch of idealism. I cannot say you are…"
4 hours ago
Belle Rose replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"....so what am I? Please tell me my philosophical horoscope;)"
4 hours ago
Belle Rose replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"Her first count was correct because there WERE 22 books. Even though she accidentally mistook one of the books for a brick, she realized it, and then also realized there was in fact one more book, so…"
4 hours ago
Strega replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"Succinct :)"
5 hours ago
_Robert_ replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"If count is a verb it was wrong. If count is a noun it was correct."
5 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"No. But if you misidentify a 12 pack of toilet paper for a piece of sushi you'll most certainly have counted incorrectly in some way at some point."
5 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"A materialist response. The accuracy of the correct identification of the objects that the person included in their set of "only books" is what's important."
6 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
"My view is that her first count is correct because of her intent when making the count. Intent is everything meaning her own subjective judgements compared with an objective identifying of the…"
6 hours ago
Davis Goodman replied to Davis Goodman's discussion 'A fun philosophy thought experiment'
6 hours ago