Florida Bill Could Make Abortion Punishable By Life In Prison
posted by: Amelia Thomson-DeVeaux - Care2
March 4, 2010

Florida Bill Could Make Abortion Punishable By Life In Prison

To most people, it seems inconceivable that a woman's legal right to choose could be taken away by anything less than a Supreme Court reversal of the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision (as we've seen during the health care debates, a woman's actual ability to access an abortion can be curtailed in many creative ways), but this Florida bill is frightening in how close it would come to banning nearly all forms of abortion. This month, Florida State Rep. Charles Van Zant, a Baptist minister, filed a bill that would make nearly all forms of abortion a first-degree felony for the provider, punishable by up to life in prison.

"I just felt like we're destroying a lot of Florida's children, and we need to stop," Van Zant said, "and I felt led by the Lord to do that."

Florida, as many know, is an extremely conservative state. Florida twice tried to enact legislation that banned late-term abortions, in 1998 and 2000, and both times the state lost in federal court because the laws were seen as too broad. The state's laws already restrict a young woman's right to an abortion; a minor (or woman under the age of 18) may not obtain an abortion until at least 48 hours after parental permission is given.

This is problematic in a number of ways (young women may not be able to tell their parents about their pregnancy because of sexual assault or incest or may be afraid of the consequences if their parents discovered that they were sexually active), but Van Zant's new bill would take this a hundred steps further. He said that he hopes if the bill is passed, that its constitutionality would be challenged so that the legality of abortion could once again be considered in court. The effects of this could be potentially devastating, since the current Supreme Court could be conservative enough to reverse the Roe decision.

"We wrote it because we expect it to be challenged in court," Van Zant said of the bill. "The Roe v. Wade decision is unconstitutional -- not this bill."

The bill, interestingly, focuses on abortion providers rather than the women accessing the abortions. Doctors who perform abortions would face first degree felonies punishable by up to life in prison and civil fines. Women would also be required to receive more information on adoption. The bill criminalizes abortion even in the case of rape or incest, a dramatic move that will hopefully keep less conservative legislators from voting for it.

Ohio and Nebraska are also attempting to restrict abortion rights. Louisiana and Utah each successfully banned abortion in 1991. Federal courts declared both those laws unconstitutional. But let's hope that this Florida bill doesn't get far enough for a court to have to strike it down.

You can tell Rep. Van Zant what you think by emailing him here.

Check out the 375 Reader Comments HERE:

Views: 26

Replies to This Discussion

This is terrible.
...while they're at it, they should outlaw "spilling semen".
All Florida males should be put in chastity devices and the keys held by their wives, Girl Friends, Or closest female blood relative. Said males would need permission to engage in sex from any of the above upon signing a legally binding document stating their intention of raising any resulting off spring with no legal obligation on the part of the mother.
I've always wanted to challenge a religious person as to why they think a child who may be aborted would be better off on the earth with a parent that hated (abused, neglected, sold) them, or a desease that crippled them. Instead of going straight to the heaven they believe in where life is assumingly perfect and painless. The logic seems a little off, but then again, when did logic and religion ever go hand in hand.
Religious idiots strike again! This is insanity! And why is a Baptist minister a state rep???? What happened to seperation of church & state?? I doubt this will pass, but I would love to hear Van Zant's explanation on why a bunch of Vatican priests were recently busted for hiring gay prostitutes.
These bronze-age desert goat-herder myth believers are anxious to bring us woman back to the dark ages, but I say Not in this lifetime! Leave me & my sisters alone, and get a life already! Damn!!
As for me I'm Against abortion, but i believe in a "woman's" right to choose. Not a child , not a 15 year old girl who got pregnant and now wants an abortion to avoid telling her parents she is sexually active....When it comes to kids under 18 i believe there needs to be parental consent. Florida is going way to far wanting to put people in prison for this...it will never pass.
Well, I think it should be a case-by-case thing. Sure, if a 15 year old just doesn't want to tell her parents she's sexually active, that's one thing. But what if the guy who impregnated her in this case was her father or step-father? What if she was raped? I'm sorry, I think it should be completely up to the 15 year old if she wants to carry her rapist's child to term... not her parents.

My mom argues that people should have to face the consequences of their actions (sex=babies), but a child is more than a just a consequence to face. If a 15 year old is forced into having a child at such a young age, then she's being forced into motherhood... she's not mature enough to choose whether she wants to be a mother because she not a "woman", yet being a mother is the responsibility of a woman! I guess it just seems like a double-standard. She's not old enough to choose, but somehow she's old enough to raise a child? And to me, giving a child up for adoption can be worse than an abortion.


Discussion Forum

Conquering Obesity

Started by Heather Spoonheim Aug 29, 2017. 0 Replies

Why I am just like Piper Chapman...what about you?

Started by Belle Rose. Last reply by Belle Rose Sep 17, 2016. 2 Replies

Hello ladies?

Started by Belle Rose Sep 27, 2014. 0 Replies

Domestic Violence Solutions...

Started by Belle Rose. Last reply by Tom Sarbeck May 12, 2013. 45 Replies

WHY must we wear a bra?

Started by Belle Rose. Last reply by Pope Beanie Mar 28, 2016. 61 Replies

¬© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service