I saw this question posed in a video and I have been wondering about it ever since. At a general level it is this: If Christians believe they go to heaven when they die, why do they preserve their life through use of seatbelts and other such safety devices? Why are they not ecstatically happy if their kids get murdered?

I also made a philosoraptor pic to ask the seatbelt question. it is the attachment.

Views: 533


Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Good answer but what about when their child dies? yes that life was originally a divine gift but wouldn't it be God's plan to take the child back away at that time? Wouldn't it then be cause for celebration that their child has been chosen to be taken back by God? that is essentially what this life is for isn't it?

This does not account for the fact that Christian believers are far more likely to try to prolong their lives with painful treatments than non-believers.  That kind of desperate hanging on to life suggests that they are unwilling to die, not that they want to cheat.

'Cause they're cowards, like the rest of us.  (They say suicide is the coward's way out, but if it were, the street would be littered with the corpses of the fallen.)
That doesn't make much sense to me... Does being brave mean you do things that you think are bad? Does breaking my leg or burning my hair prove that I am not a coward? Or does it prove I am a madman? :D

Doesn't that sort of make you feel like a sociopath? 

I'm just saying, I don't even let my friends walk home alone at night for fear of being mugged.

Because I love them. 

And muggings aren't a huge deal. 

But eternal suffering and agony and all that stuff Christians believe in? (Assuming you do, of course. I realize there are many forms of Christianity, and I'd not want to misrepresent you if that isn't the case.)

If I thought someone I cared for was honestly, genuinely going to face an eternity of agony, I would not let them leave my presence until I was assured of their safety. I would tie them to a chair. This life is fleeting if you believe in an afterlife like that, right? No crime you commit in the effort to save them would be anything but compassionate, right?

So are you out there doing that? Does it keep you up at night? 

How would you be happy in heaven knowing someone you live is burning in hell? 

Or do you just not have atheist loved ones? 

Just curious. No malice meant, though I understand these are sort of tough questions. 


You realize you follow a god that is going to torture your best friend for all eternity simply because the guy (or girl) took a look at all the evidence and came to a conclusion based on that evidence, personal experience and his own mindset? 

Which means god either purposefully or by negligence created him with said mindset, which lead to the personal experiences which led to his conclusion of said evidence. 

Which means if god is all powerful, he created your friend to be atheist and is now going to punish him for it. If he's not all powerful, then I'd start shopping for a better god.

I mean, I'm not even going to get into the absurdities of a spirit sacrificing his son who is really himself for sins of the world that he created (And we could take this all the way back to creation. An all knowing god putting a talking snake in a garden with a forbidden fruit that was VERY suspiciously placed is an easy target for me, but this isn't about me....) 



I mean, I'll be the first to admit that I'm not the best person in the world. I let my friends down all the time. 

But holy crap. That's scary. 


I don't give a shit who you are. Even if god were to appear to me right now in my living room and tell me "Look bitch, it doesn't have to make sense. It's this way because I said so!" I would straight up reply with "Alright, then. I feel you are unjust and evil, so I'll take the hell option, please!" 


You are really ok with your god torturing good, honest, hard working and loving people just because they don't believe a very scattered, conflicting, confusing religion? 

You willingly follow that? For real? 

And you like.. go on about your day, not really doing very much about it at all? 



Misty wrote:  "How would you be happy in heaven knowing someone you live is burning in hell?"


d.clair. replied:  I have no idea


@ d.clair - The answer is you would not feel happy unless your memory was erased. So if you believe in this concept of the Christian heaven, that is what will have to happen.


What kind of a just God would erase the love, for example, a mother has for her child just because the child decided there was not enough evidence to accept whatever the heck he would need to accept in order to get into your concept of heaven.


Your child could be a good loving child. He could grow up to love his own children and work hard to provide for them. He could be a kind and compassionate person. But no, just because he does not accept your myth of Christianity, he will suffer for infinity and beyond. Why can't you see how preposterous this line of thinking is. Wake up! Please. For Goodness sake. 

Nothing good enters hell. Hell is a place, or a state, or whatever, that is completely devoid of God's presence. You should really read C. S. Lewis's Great Divorce if you would like to understand this. However, I am in fact not sure that you would. Would you? :D

Nothing good enters hell. Hell is a place, or a state, or whatever, that is completely devoid of God's presence. You should really read C. S. Lewis's Great Divorce if you would like to understand this. However, I am in fact not sure that you would. Would you? :


@ ondrej - I read that when I was a Christian. It left me confused as hell and helped me realize what a bunch of bunk religion is.

C.S. Lewis is not accepted as a canonical writer by any Christian tradition. This doctrine is just his opinion and not universally accepted by all Christians..


It is, however, a very convenient way of getting around the awkward clash between a god who is claimed to be completely loving and one who creates evil, makes wagers with the devil and throws people in an eternal torture chamber because they don't believe the right things before they die.

It does not match what the gospel writers believe that Jesus taught without a lot of word twisting and semantic assaults and somersaults. 

Of course! And Lewis himself would have it no other way, I am sure. :) After all, he was no theologian.


However I do not think that makes his explanation any less valid. After all, his books have earned him a lot of respect, I even hear some Catholic bishops quoting him from time to time. :D


Anyway, I do not think his explanation does not match gospels. If your previous posts are any indication I will not agree with the arguments that you may present to support that claim, but in spite of that I would like to hear them very much. Actually – is it possible that some author or other has already addressed those issues in writing so that one can perhaps read such well-composed and carefully reasoned argument? That might help. :) Any links?


Btw. I believe that the Anglican Church has pronounced C. S. Lewis a hero of faith, which seems to be basically as close as they get towards pronouncing a person a saint these days... :D

How do you rectify the need to believe the great myth that god works in mysterious ways and in the end all will know he was right... with the fact that we have the capacity to understand suffering and assign blame to god here and now


As for an intellectual out for hell its quite easy.


1. The torah has one occurrence of a word that means netherworld similar to hades not a place of suffering just a place of afterlife. Judaism has no set dogma on life after death beyond a vague idea that there is an afterlife and when the messiah finally arrives that the faithful may gain eternal life.


2. The gospels ... being the 3 that were chosen by committee to enter the bible not the 200+ others that were not chosen ...all have different accounts of Hell ..  jesus speaks at length about it but has differing words on the subject. In Matthew Jesus goes to hell for 3 days and 3 nights. This trip to hell isnt mentioned in the other 2.


Its not hard just takes a little bit of critical thinking and reasoning.




© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service