It almost seems like atheists don't want to believe in God. Do you just simply not want to believe in God because you don't want to give up your own free will?

ADMIN EDIT: Mercedes has left ThinkAtheist.com on her own accord. This discussion will remain, however do not expect a response from the author. 

~Dan.

Views: 11535

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

All the writings of J. K. Rowling point to the existence of Harry Potter as much as all the unknown long dead authors, editors, and annotators of the various bibles point to the existence of supernatural beings. Same thing.

That's a really stupid comparison. I don't see how you equate Harry Potter with the Bible.

You seem so stuck on the bible. What about the tens of dozens of  other holy books, some much older than the bible and most which are alot more internally consistent. Do they prove that that vishnu ,krishna, allah and the tao exist?

Both were written by Humans, which, by your own words, makes both of them authentic.

Humans are imaginitive and quite capable of creating such a work without divine intervention. And there is current and respectible argument that Jesus (Joshua) did not actually exist as a historic figure but was simply the central figure of a mystery cult that later became Christianity. Given that more recent archeology has started to cast doubt on biblical stories and its general authenticity using it to support any theological argument becomes very shaky ground indeed. The Bible was written for believers, not for skeptics.

It's not a circular argument though. God exists within us and we know his presence in many ways. The bible is one of them. I don't get it.

Ok. Stop trying to "win," and just step back and think about it for a second.

Any person can write a book about anything. What is written can be real, or it can be a story. It can be thought to be real, but still turn out to be a story. It can be a little bit real, but mostly made up. That's because people are wondrously imaginative, and can spin words in an incredible amount of ways.

The Bible is a book (a set of books, if you will). It could be real! But it could also be just a story, or only a little bit real.

How can we know whether or not it's real?

There are a lot of ways we can check, actually--but the very worst way, in fact not a way at all, is to say that it just is, or to say that it is because it says it is.

You could say the same of any other book! If Rapunzel had a line that said "nobody should add anything or take anything away from this account; it is true," would you believe it just because it said that? I wouldn't. And hey, maybe Rapunzel was a real girl, or maybe there was a girl like her once. But that's completely irrelevant.

It is exactly the definition and finest example of a circular argument to claim that the Bible or Jesus are true because they say they are true.

Now, as for your claim of "God exists within us and we know his presence in many ways." With that you've just opened up an entirely new argument/can of worms in an attempt to change tactics. If you really want me to tackle that one I'll do it after some sleep, but I do hope you first understand that your argument about the Bible and Jesus standing alone as proof has been thoroughly refuted. And it would be a shame to move on if we hadn't at least come to that understanding.

Excellent response.

How can we know whether or not it's real?

because it all matches each other and other ancient books do not. It all point to God among us and us with Him. It is a collection of books of people and their relationship with God and Him with us and He lives within  to this day.

Odd that you hold a good editor makes for truth. Is there anything else?

RSS

Support T|A

Think Atheist is 100% member supported

All proceeds go to keeping Think Atheist online.

Donate with Dogecoin

Members

Forum

Things you hate.

Started by Devlin Cuite in Small Talk. Last reply by Tom Sarbeck 30 seconds ago. 131 Replies

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Services we love

We are in love with our Amazon

Book Store!

Gadget Nerd? Check out Giz Gad!

Into life hacks? Check out LabMinions.com

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2014   Created by Dan.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service