What will be the fate of 'Under God' in Massachusetts and other states?

A family of Humanists in Massachusetts just asked a judge to order an end to the state mandated, teacher led, daily declaration in public schools that the nation is “under God" via the Pledge of Allegiance.

The one previous challenge that reached the Supreme Court of the United States was based on the First Amendment, but they dismissed the case on a technicality without ruling on 'Under God', stating that the plaintiff who brought the case lacked standing.

This case uses a different tactic. It's the first to seek equal rights for atheists and humanists based on the right to equal protection under a state constitution. The legal basis is that (1) any public school activity of a patriotic nature must be nondiscriminatory and (2) “under God” discriminates against atheists and humanists by making believers into patriotic insiders, and nonbelievers into unpatriotic outsiders.

In many ways, the case is following the same roadmap that gay rights advocates used in Massachusetts starting in 2003. They sued the state citing the same equal rights guarantees and won the legal right to marry. Massachusetts became the first state to issue gay marriage licenses and then gay rights advocates in other states copied the same model.

So this could be huge with 'Under God'. The idea is that if this tactic wins with 'Under God' in Massachusetts, then it could win for atheists in other states who adopt the same methods. I suppose, as with marriage equality, we'd end up with two different kinds of states where the Pledge is concerned. Kids in the red states will be saying the post-McCarthyism pledge, and kids in the blue states will be saying the pre-McCarthyism Pledge. Up north we'll be "one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice" and down south we'll be "one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice."

What do you think? Will 'Under God' prevail in Massachusetts? Or will atheists finally win equal rights under the law like everyone else? If we do, do you think it will proliferate to other states? Why or why not?

Tags: Allegiance, God, Pledge, Under, of

Views: 244

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Well thank god we agree on something, Gallup!


© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service