Before I pose my question, I will clarify what I mean by 'punitive justice' in this context.


'Justice' means only the creation and enforcement of laws by a recognized political agency/ authority.  There is no implication that these laws are just or moral per se.


'Punitive' means that the afore mentioned law enforcement punishes by design.  The law making and enforcing agencies deliberately punish offenders for their crimes under the belief that punishment has intrinsic value. 


The question I pose is this: Is there still a place for punitive justice in modern society?  


This isn't intended a 'yes' or 'no' question.  Shades of grey are encouraged.  Various anarchistic views are also relevant.  I don't care about thread drift here provided it is drift and not total derailment.  Perhaps I'm thinking too narrowly on this subject.





On a side note, disagreeing with my views on this subject is punishable with death by forced Glenn Beck marathon!!!!  Grrr.

Views: 1044

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

One must also contextually assume that the use of the word re-arrest also includes conviction and imprisonment. I don't like assuming anything, especially when statistics are involved. Especially when you see the same article talking about arrest charges in a contextual manner that does not imply conviction or imprisonment.

I just found that the article from wiki actually left me with more questions than answers. What's the saying? "There's lies, damn lies, and statistics"
Haha. True, true. I'm taking it all in on a contigency basis, anyway. Grains of salt all around.
How rare are psychopaths, anyway?

I don't know. If I'm not mistaken, the term psychopath was dropped for a period of time. I think it was replaced by antisocial personality disorder. The incidence of antisocial personality disorder is something like 3% in males and 1% in females.

The problem is, there are different types or subgroups of antisocial personality disorder, and I don't think they all fit the concept of psychopathy we are talking about here. In this case, I don't quite know how to meaningfully deal with what feels like ambiguity. Perhaps I just need to read up and get informed.
I guess clear definitions aren't always easy. My layman's understanding is that psychopaths are rare. More common are sociopaths.

I think I need to read up more and get informed, too.
Maybe recidivism will be higher for the pedophiles.

Very possible. I'm almost afraid to research it online.
Unfortunately, there is a whole class of people we could describe as society's "underbelly". They don't understand rehabilitation. They don't want rehabilitation. They want to kill their (perceived) enemies or they want easy money or they want sex with frightened strangers or whatever.

The human condition encompasses the full gamut of people. Some of them are simply sick fucking people; without any hope of rehabilitation. That's the truth I've found in my experience thus far.
The question is about punishment though. If some people are 'sick fucking people' with no hope of rehabilitation, would it not be a waste of energy to actively punish them?
But punishment is so festive!
I don't follow your reasoning.

I am very judgemental. I try not to be.  My simple reference is the golden rule, clarified to include everyone with a nervous system and the ability to feel sadness or pain.  The eastern religions first teaching of "Ahimsa", which means :"Do no harm" works well.  Anyone who chooses to cause the suffering of others for his own benefit, is acting badly, in my view.

I feel rage at those who abuse, starve, rape, or kill someone (including other animals) over whom they have power.  I feel vengeful.  I imagine poetic justice.  I want to carry it out.  I might "turn the other cheek" for injustices against me, and I may be forgiving.  When the injustice is against some powerless "other", I want retribution.  I admit this generally unacceptable point of view.  Still, I do do wish to give the power of severe punishment to my government.  I do not trust them.

Is there still a place for punitive justice in modern society? 

What a great question to think about and pose. Thanks for posting this. I'm curious, is there anything in particular that you have been reading or hearing about that brought this topic to your mind?

 

Punitive Justice almost sounds like it could be an oxymoron to me. Punishment might have nothing to do with justice. Equating the two may just be a rationalization to help make the one administering the punishment feel they are doing the "right" thing.

 

Alfie Kohn has done years of research and writing on the subject of punishments and rewards. In fact, he has a fascinating book called "Punished by Rewards" that I highly recommend checking out. He often talks about the subject in the context of education, but it is applicable to other realms where punishments or rewards are used (government policy, law enforcement, interpersonal relationships, etc.)

Punishment and reward proceed from basically the same psychological model, one that conceives of motivation as nothing more than the manipulation of behavior. ~Alfie Kohn

We have a whole society that is very entrenched in the idea of using punishments and rewards to manipulate people into behaving the way we think they should. While these techniques sometimes work in the short term, they are almost always nothing but a short term fix and are generally counter-productive in the long run because they never address the most important issue: what are the motivations behind a person's behaviors.

RSS

  

Forum

Disorders of Sex Development

Started by ɐuɐz ǝllǝıuɐp in Small Talk. Last reply by ɐuɐz ǝllǝıuɐp 2 minutes ago. 7 Replies

It happened

Started by Belle Rose in Atheist Parenting. Last reply by ɐuɐz ǝllǝıuɐp 19 minutes ago. 75 Replies

Ken Hamm at it again

Started by Noel in Small Talk. Last reply by Ed 2 hours ago. 1 Reply

Living freely.

Started by Quincy Maxwell in Society. Last reply by Ed 2 hours ago. 22 Replies

Deepak's challenge

Started by Davis Goodman in Small Talk. Last reply by Gregg R Thomas 2 hours ago. 25 Replies

Events

Blog Posts

Labels

Posted by Quincy Maxwell on July 20, 2014 at 9:37pm 3 Comments

Services we love

We are in love with our Amazon

Book Store!

Gadget Nerd? Check out Giz Gad!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

In need a of a professional web site? Check out the good folks at Clear Space Media

© 2014   Created by Dan.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service