A friend of mine posted this on facebook. Of course this kid was the biggest, shady drug addict and thief when he was a teenager. Then he "found god". I try really hard to ignore shit like this the best I can. What would you guys do? Not specifically for this actual posting, just in general. When people you know post crap like this online, or you overhear friends making snarky comments what do you do? I didn't comment on this. It's kind of funny. If it was malicious, then I would have.
Or you could point out that his entire definition of Atheism is invalid. The first part is a version of abiogenesis (it falls under cosmology) and the second part is a horrible, one-liner of evolution (it falls under biology). I guess you could finish by telling him that Atheism is very simply the condition of NOT believing in a god... a god who creates people who are too stupid to know what atheism is.
I think I would try to explain to him the fact that atheism has absolutely nothing to do with the things you believe. When theists say things like this they are trying to bring non belief down to their level. It is truly pitiful if you ask me. It is even funnier when they try and say non believers are illogical and our arguments are completely irrational.
Meghan, I would not post in his wall. Just de-friend him or "shut him up" by unsubscribing from his updates (you can now do that). No point in answering - he will not change - it would mean that he left the drugs for nothing! :-)
My two cents' worth...
That sounds like the Christian thing to do… run away in offense and de-friend someone for presenting an unfavorable opinion. I’d like to think we’re better than that.
Personally, I’d take the opportunity to educate them on what atheism actually is and pursue the resulting discussion. This type of behavior and animosity towards atheists comes from pure ignorance and fear. None of that will be alleviated if we don’t take the opportunity to engage in discussion and educate.
That's the way to do it...nice and gentle, leading them forward without them hardly realizing it until they've stumbled into a new discovery. Otherwise they become defensive out of pride or fear and completely close their mind off.
Nelson's reply is right on point; I wish I'd said it.
So then, what do I do? I post comments like the following:
No, our knowledge of the universe does not yet make perfect sense. But, unlike the fantasy-based god conjecture, it makes SOME sense. Thanks to the scientific method and the courageous striving of scientists, we get closer every day to making sense of everything. Science expands toward the future; cowardly religion retreats into the past. Religion makes NO progress; it seeks NO truth; it ABHORS the truth; it is stuck in the bronze age where it HIDES from the truth. It shrinks fearfully in its medieval bunker where it conjures up supernatural visions of a WISHED-FOR truth. Science does experiments to get CLOSER to the truth; religion burns witches to ESCAPE the truth. And what is that inevitable truth? We are ALL going to die and cease to exist in ANY WAY. Get over it!
people who post stuff like that are just baiting those who don't agree and pandering to those who do agree with them. . .your response will not likely change their pov. . .but if you feel strongly about it then give a logical, thought-out, unemotional answer
or you could just "hide" and not have to read that crap :)
A weak mind looks for an all encompassing answer.
Fear of the unknown and the unknowable creates the need for those
that are weak minded, to believe in the universal "sky Daddy".
I just love the whole intelligent design argument.
Makes about as much sense in explaining something as
why pancakes taste great with butter and maple syrup.
The FACT is...no deity was necessary.
Then again...maybe that deity is physics?
More answers are to be found there, then within a bible.
On facebook and wherever online I generally ignore things like this. I tend to respond only when someone comments on something I wrote. Stuff like this doesn't really mean anything, at least to me. It's bumper sticker stuff, not philosophically important.
When confronted with things like this, my philosophy is "Temper your integrity with compassion." But when in doubt, I guess I act like someone working in a mental health facility-- let it go if it doesn't harm anyone.
I only really speak up when it concerns children. I'd just about crucify someone for indoctrinating kids because I consider it mutilation and know how sick it makes the world, but short of that I usually just do what some other people posting here do; throw in some short and light sarcasm and go to sleep telling myself that their silliness is dying out with them.