The title says it all, was Jesus the right choice? To give a little back ground Jesus was not the only Messiah during the firt century. There were many others claiming to be the child of God, so why was Jesus picked out of the hay stack?

Views: 1179

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Well, gee, I would hope it would be the Norse creator gods, Odin, Vili, and Vé, who created the world out of the body and blood of the giant frost ogre Ymir.

Then I choose Dionysus, the ultimate party animal! Drinks are on the house - BYOL (bring your own ladder)!

Seconded. If this is a voting thing.

"That the best thing for a man is not to be born, and if already born, to die as soon as possible."
- Silenus

Premise 1: if Pokemon did not exist, then the applicability of math to the natural world would be a happy coincidence.
Premise 2: the applicability of math to the natural world is not a happy coincidence.
Conclusion: Pokemon exists

You see, the main problem with this argument is not that it's evidence for God particularly. Okay, Pokemon was silly, but why isn't it an equally valid argument for Brahma (the Hindu creator), Ahura Mazda (the Zoroastrian creator), or Izanagi and Izanami (the Shinto co-creators)? It's kind of a fill in the blanks argument that works for any number of possible deities. It in no way points directly to the Christian God even if you accept the argument,...

...which you shouldn't. Here's why:

Let's look at Premise 2. Setting aside that the word "Happy" is unnecessary to the validity of the argument, look at it this way: the universe couldn't exist without a structure (what we call the laws of physics), a structure which the human invention we call math simply describes. It may be that our universe is itself an event, possibly a coincidence, that happened in a much larger reality. I regard that as fairly likely, but that's just an opinion.

Pokemon was a good substitution, because the precept is silly.  You explained it well.

Isn't it fun, picking out our preferred gods?  much nicer to pick one out that doesn't have such appalling relationship issues.

Generally I would agree that the argument in whole is silly because you can just sustitute words, however you have to defend your premises. I can't quite remember how Dr. Craig defended this one (I think is was something along the lines of math being applicable to the natural world because God made it that way and man simply discovered it that way). I would agree with you guys, you make much better points than Dr. Craig :)

I think is was something along the lines of math being applicable to the natural world because God made it that way and man simply discovered it that way.

I certainly hope that wasn't his argument because that involves proving the second premise by invoking the conclusion. Premises are supposed to support (imply) the conclusion, not vice versa.


You claimed that there is no evidence for the Big Bang ....

Sam made the "historians agree" claim  etc

Can we just leave it there please ... Im over it

I didn't say there was no BB, I said there was evidence to support several different theories about the Big Bang - you were saying that without evidence, it didn't happen, and I was demonstrating that evidence can be misleading. Obviously, the Big Bang happened only one way, and we have yet to determine exactly what that one way was, but we're OK with that, the theory will be adjusted as new evidence comes in.

The same with Jesus, or Yeshua, I was 90% convinced he never existed, but though it wasn't evidence, in the classical sense, Steve showed me a perspective I hadn't previously considered, which in my mind, reduced that likelihood to 60%, down from 90%.

NOW we can leave it.

BTW - you still haven't elaborated on why you feel religion is important in the world and should be maintained.

The discovery by Dr. Hubble that the universe is expanding in all directions tells us there was a BB. One simply rolls the expansion backwards as a contraction and it all converges back to a singularity. That is proof enough for the BB, but how BB's happen is (and may always be) an open question.

While I have your attention, if you've grown tired of the bikini girl or Hello Kitty wallpaper on your computer now, go here to find wallpapers of some of the spectacular shots made by Hubble's telescope.

I can't imagine ever getting tired of the bikini girl.


Oh, that's right - that only applies to me --

Hey guys, I started a thread about the new pope
check it out, leave your thoughts




Started by Jake LaFort in Small Talk. Last reply by Madelyn Picard 5 hours ago. 3 Replies

Do humans benefit the Earth? If so, explain.

Started by Tyrion in Small Talk. Last reply by Gregg RThomas 12 hours ago. 22 Replies

Poem: Clergy

Started by Fred Hampton in Religion and the Religious, Atheism and Atheists. Last reply by Gregg RThomas 16 hours ago. 1 Reply

Ernesto Che' Guevara

Started by Fred Hampton in Quotes. Last reply by Fred Hampton 1 hour ago. 21 Replies

Fred Hampton Is New Here

Started by Fred Hampton in Welcome to Think Atheist. Last reply by Fred Hampton on Tuesday. 8 Replies

Blog Posts

I am Ayaz Nizami

Posted by Noon Alif on March 27, 2017 at 10:30am 13 Comments

Seraphims and Cherubims

Posted by Fred Hampton on March 27, 2017 at 2:04am 0 Comments

© 2017   Created by umar.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service