armed with a degree in theology, over the years i have come up with specific questions to ask of christians.

indeed i even attend "alpha courses" (introductory courses to becoming a christian) and put these questions to the hosts (usually under the guise of "well i'm thinking of becoming a christian but i have some questions...)

confrontation and causing offense gets you nowhere. also being impolite just reinforces their smug assertion that atheists are angry.


the question i have had most success with at putting people on the spot goes like this...


"a priest rapes a choirboy. the choirboy becomes depressed and traumatized, rejects jesus and the church (understandably), turns to drugs, dies young and spends an eternity in hell, unsaved and condemned by god.

the priest repents on his deathbed, embraces christ, is forgiven and spends forever in heaven.

by what measure can we consider this to be justice?"


i'm hoping that this question might one day become a meme, so that anyone who brings up the subject of christianity is immediately reminded of this question and has an answer demanded of them.


i have many other questions like this that cannot be simply swatted away with theology, mystery or dogma.

i'd be happy to share them with anyone who is interested.


thanks for reading, let me know if it has an impact on anyone you ask.






Tags: christ, debate, question, redemption

Views: 3301

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

i like to ask them why god chose some obscure tribe in a barren land to reveal his greatness when there were other civilizations far more advanced to which he could have gotten his 'universal' message to the most people in one attempt. i also find it very interesting that god has not 'revealed' himself in this age of instant access to all parts of the globe. should he just do that, he would have no problem getting all 7 billion of us to accept his claims, but, that may be asking him to actually be involved in his 'creation' now wouldn't it?


did god not know that his plan would cause untold suffering and wars for thousands of years and that many would kill and be killed in his name for his cause? and he seems to have no issue with that, as long as someone still believes? does that make you feel like a lab rat like it does me?


just a few ramblings :D

indeed it is a good point to ask them "why judea? why 1st century?". i think i heard hitch using it in his debates.

i used to ask it of christians a lot myself. now such questions feel like arguing over the details, and in doing so tacitly admitting their might be an intellectual discussion to be had.

the questions i ask now have no reasonable answers at all, and that's what makes them so effective.

your question of the pain and suffering caused by his creation is answered using theology of free-will and the problem of evil. not real answers but good enough for those who need to believe.



One of my favourite questions is to ask why they bother praying, if their god has a "perfect will". 


No matter what your prayer is, it's either "in scope" with the "Plan", or it isn't. And since god can't be "omniscient" and still change its mind (wrap your brain around that paradox!) prayer is pointless. 

well, the problem then becomes one of the description of 'free-will' which is not actually in the bible as described by the theology of men. god makes it very clear that all is foreknown and predetermined and that he is above and beyond what we consider time. calvin was quite accurate in his description of pre-destination as opposed to the armenian belief in free will.


IF we have free will, then the belief of predestination can not be true and most of the dogma of paul must be thrown out and all theological directives that indicate we chose to believe or not MUST become the norm in all of christendom, but that has never been accepted by the vast majority of theologians because IF we are truly free, then the god of the bible created us that way and his plan of salvation which relies on his ability to KNOW that man would fall and KNOW that we need salvation is clearly a fabrication.

IF predestination is true, then faith is god's gift to man though not all receive it, that being said, HOW can a just god condemn anyone who was NOT given this gift of faith with any integrity and any sense of justice. we then are merely lab rats to the god experiment of his creation, if that is true, then that is NOT a god i am willing to believe in... :D

from here, the discussion can go many different ways :D


and btw, in isaiah 45:7, it CLEARLY states that GOD is the author of evil! don't get many willing to discuss that one with me :D IF god sends evil our way, to 'test' us as naive christians want to believe to have any hope their god is still good, then he is evil incarnate, not lucifer! the ultimate fall guy! :D

And add to that the fact that Biblegod killed something like 3 million people in the Old Testament, and Satan is responsible for only ten - Job's family. And for that, he had the _direct permission of Yahweh to do so_. 

i also like to ask them why god repented he had made man, if he made them perfect :D tough to get a good response from that one!

“And it repented Jehovah that he had made man upon the earth, and it grieved him at his heart” (Gen. 6:6).

The reason he revealed himself to one small tribe is to show how great he is. It's like every other example in the Bible of where he use the small guy to accomplish something great: because if he used the big guy, the big guy could boast and say it was all him. If he used the small guy, then the small guy can pint it back to God. Yes, God has a perfect plan, and I can't begin to say I know what it is. I can't claim to know why anything works and what God is planning. But I knew he has everything in mind wen e lets what happens happen. Now, I know this may seem like a REALLY pathetic answer, so let me give you an example. When I went to take my permit test, I ha to have my Noterized Proof of Attendnace from my school. Well, I accidentally left it at home. My mom was SOOO mad at me. Problem was, there were eighteen million people there, and I had to get braces on that afternoon. So, we went home and got it just in case we'd have time afterward, although, we didn't really think we would. Well, after I got my braces on, we had enough time to zip over there and take it. While we were riding over there, I notice one of the forms we had to have with us had to be Noterized, and it wasn't. My mom and I were able to get it Noterized and go to the place so I could take me test. We were the ONLY people in there. See? Something bad that works toward good. Something bad: leaving my form at home, meaning I would have to come back some other time, and we didn't know when because of work schedules and crap. Something good: I was able to catch something we needed to do, and we would've waited in line forever only to fin out I couldn't take the test if I hadn't caught it, and we didn't have to wait in line. See? So, in the moment, you might not be able to see anything good, but in the end, it will work out. Want a Biblical reference, go study Joseph's life in Genesis.

Hi Myah and welcome to Think Atheist. So you forgot your Proof of Attendance form and then your God, the Creator of the Universe intervened to clear the room for you? Is that what you are suggesting? You don't think there is a more plausible explanation?

Have you heard of the term "Confirmation Bias"?

I don't know about that Myah, sometimes things just go "tits up", "Pete Tong", wrong.  You don't always get home. 

I will say though that I seem to see a pattern where if you try hard for something, courageously and unselfishly, good luck often seems to drop right out of the sky, as it were. 

I agree with the point you're making, but I imagine the response would be something along these lines:

Yes, the priest did a terrible thing, but if he truly accepted Christ, God is merciful and he will be forgiven and allowed into heaven (or whatever).  The boy during the course of his short and tragic life had the opportunity to turn back to the church but instead made the decision to self destruct, thus hell.

 Doesn't make any sense, but I suspect that would be very close to the rationalization that would be used to justify the boy's unending torture at the hands of his loving god, and the rapists eternal reward for apologizing.  Or something.

yes very true indeed that is pretty much the only response available to them.


at which point i look puzzled and say "so you're saying that it is fair?"


either that or just change the word "rape" to "murder". repeat the question.

From their perspective it does appear to seem fair which causes me no end of frustration when having those sorts of conversations.


© 2015   Created by umar.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service