Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Unseen on May 31, 2013 at 8:50pm

I was wondering if a little circular reasoning was inflating the column for "mental illness" as a cause of suicide. Someone who for rational reasons, in other words, who talks about wanting to commit suicide, might ipso facto be declared mentally ill by a clinician, if only as a CYA.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Strega on May 31, 2013 at 9:23pm

I had to Google CYA.  Cover Your Ass

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Unseen on May 31, 2013 at 9:59pm

Must be an Americanism.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Ed on May 31, 2013 at 11:24pm

Euthanasia is accepted and practiced without a cocked eyebrow in northern Europe. There is certainly many a valid reason for self termination in my mind's eye. Who is the person to judge another weak and unstable for their unwillingness to deal with the host of issues that life throws at us? I have had more than one friend place a bullet through their brain. Who am I to say they were wrong?

It should certainly be the right of an individual to self terminate. Society or religion can offer guidance but ultimately it is the individual's choice. Personally I have thought about suicide at various times in my life and decided the burden of depression was temporary and that tomorrow just might be better than today. 

I would certainly experience many a sleepless night if I encountered 3 suicides or attempts in such a short span of time. While many make the decision to terminate early in their lives the ones I especially am troubled by the thousands of shell shocked former military who return to their country and as a result of being victimized by PTSD they take their life. 

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Ed on May 31, 2013 at 11:10pm

Not sure the source of that chart but I would wager financial problems is actually higher on the list of reasons.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by archaeopteryx on June 1, 2013 at 9:37pm

I rarely use statistics to establish anything, generally I prefer expert testimony or good, old-fashioned logic.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Melvinotis on June 2, 2013 at 2:13am

JD, my heart goes out to you because I had a similar set of back to back attempts by people around me in 1985. None successful, but all with difficult aftermaths.


I won't go into the circumstances of them here, but I'll add this. Religion/endurance of the soul can figure in to the suicidal thought process, but rarely as a primary driver. What I would say leads the process is an awareness that the person is different than the world around them in a philosophical or existential way that conflicts with their own self worth. This can be codified and substantialized by religious doctrines.

I am not saying that religion cannot be a primary factor, just that other issues tend to be the "reason" , and religion can be a highly mitigating factor.

Besides 1985, I've been exposed to more than my fair share of suicide attempts by friends, relatives, and acquaintances. I wish you strength and mental peace.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by archaeopteryx on June 2, 2013 at 2:25am

As some here on the board already know, BiPolar Disorder can also be a factor. I lost a daughter to suicide - her note began, "I am broken, and I cannot be fixed." I am in the process of writing a book that I hope, may save lives, using the title my daughter posthumously suggested.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Unseen on June 2, 2013 at 9:27am

I see the role of religion in suicide as a mixed bag. For every person driven to suicide in some sense by religion, there may be someone who is kept from suicide by it. For negative reasons, of course: the "straight to Hell" aspect for sure, or feeling guilt over the aftermath they know they would leave behind which they feel is sinful, or the effect specifically on parents with "honor thy father and mother" in mind. 

I just don't see it easy to look at it entirey one way or the other. 

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Judith van der Roos on June 2, 2013 at 7:53am

I am not, nor have ever been religious in any form. I am gay but have never experienced any bullying because of it, my family are entirely accepting of the whole spectrum of sexuality. I have once tried to kill myself though. The decision to try was a quick one, I had not really spent time considering it. It was born of unrelenting physical pain six months into a two year recovery from extensive injuries and the simple practical conclusion that the pain I was experiencing despite a morphine pumping driving the drug directly into my spinal cord was not going to go away any time soon and I wanted rest from it. One evening the nurse had refilled the pump but in her rush to complete her drug round had not actually closed the locking cover over the syringe driver which on that type of pump meant the interlock to the magic little button was not engaged and so I could press it as often as I wanted. I guess I spent about five minutes thinking on this, there were no conversations with "god", no questions about the morality of what I was considering because I had been raised without the baggage of "belief" and "sin". I had however been raised in a society that allows people the option of ending their lives if they so wish.

So I considered my future. Fifteen surgeries down, sone twenty or more to go. Every physio session was a trip into even more pain. I could not hear, I could not speak, my hands barely functioned and I was tormented by nightmares every time I finally managed to sleep. My family had already braced themselves for my death several times so were as well prepared as they could ever be so it came down to a choice of more pain or no pain, nothing, zip, nada. I chose nada and kept hitting that button and watch the driver push the syringe down, down, down.

Imagine my considerable surprise when I woke up twenty nightmare free hours later. My first thought was "NUTS" and then the pain came in and I just got on with yet another day, then another, and another and another.

My conclusion, the Universe has a sense of humor.

If a person decides to end their life, as long as it does not endanger others (the bridge guy being a case in point) then you should be able to go for it, guilt free.
Regards,
Judith vd R.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by archaeopteryx on June 2, 2013 at 1:11pm

You've also mentioned your deafness, Judith, so I know that life hasn't been easy for you, but I know that you are married now, and presumably happy, and you, yourself, admitted: "The decision to try was a quick one" - don't you agree that anyone attempting such a permanent move, should undergo some form of counseling, to make sure this isn't just a temporary decision that, upon reconsideration, is likely to be abandoned?

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Judith van der Roos on June 3, 2013 at 12:21pm

It was a decision based merely on circumstances at the time, when every single little movement produced pain, when everything either happened to me or was imposed upon me in lieu of any meaningful communication. Once all your dignity is stripped away as you pee through tubes, open your bowels into a slip pan and twice a day have your parts on display to change dressings I can assure you that it changes how your mind works. Removal of the ability to influence events happening to you combined with pain not even the most powerful opiates can dull, changes one's mental landscape for the worse, something I am sure the School Of the Americas taught their torturers a long time ago. At that time I would argue that it was a logical decision based on the information available, experience to date and knowledge of what was to come, I would have tried again in the following few weeks if the I hd been able. As to counselling, well they did send a couple of shrinks but they were worse than useless. Counselling is very hit and miss taking time to strike a relationship where you can work together, and frankly ones mental state might simply overtake time.

My point is saying all this that for everyone there are circumstances where death is just the right choice for the time given that those things they hold dear have been stripped away. - dignity, privacy, self determination, or something imposed like pain.

Yes I survived, yes I have a lovely family and they make me happy and content and I am happy to be alive. however our life belongs to us and while others might be stakeholders in it they do not own it and so it is entirely up to ourselves to decide on its continuation.

Side note: I have always found it utterly baffling how some nation states have laws against attempting to kill oneself and yet they have the death penalty clearly showing that they feel they have the right to end your life while you do not.

• ▶ Reply

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• …
• 8
• 9
• 10
• 11
• Next ›
• Page