I am not for war, but is it sometimes necessary? Ask Americans why we are at war and you will get different answers.

We provide healthcare for other countries when thousands of Americans can't afford insurance. We put our troops in danger for another country's "freedom". We have alliances that make enemies of other countries. We supply and support Israel. All for what? How exactly does this benefit America?

Should we continue doing what we have been doing or should we just stay over here and mind our own business? I am eager to see how other atheists view this.

Views: 342

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

It benefits the Capitalists, as it maintains chaos.  Chaos is required for the Capitalists to maintain the status quo, because if there was no chaos, there would be rebellion against the system itself.

 

They lie to people in other countries, and tell them they will be "rich" in order to "switch" their system from Socialism or Communism.  Then they turn it into a Capitalist system where the Corporations are all American owned with cheap sources of labor, and officials who are paid off goons.  You can read about it The Economic Hitman"--even Vietnam was an "Economic War."

Thanks, I couldn't remember the exact title of the book....but it certainly changed the way I looked at governments and the news media.  I am going to check the other book you cited as well.
But that's what they usually do, don't they? According to G. W. Bush, the US's interference with Afghanistan and Iraq was a just cause. Who are you to decide what is 'just' when a democratically elected (ahem) head of state thinks otherwise? ;-)
I would take the description of "assist" one step further. I would not provide assistance that was military in nature. Only humanitarian where there is not one side you are taking against another.  Example: famine, drought, tsunami, earthquake assistance.

Absolutely.

And furthermore (and still on-topic), perhaps we could have (e.g.) cost-effectively helped prevent some devastation in Haiti before their earthquake, by helping them improve their living conditions. But of course that kind of focus is even further off than focusing on the nearer term post-disaster aid.

That kind of aid would bring no benefit to our charity organisations... unfortunately, even charity is a business, especially among the religious, which is a major influx to Haiti, keeping them poor and subdued. In our society charity rarely accomplishes improvement, it mostly only accomplishes self-aggrandisement. They don't need our charity, they need us to stop interfering with their economy, and allow low cost non-profit-based knowledge transfers so they can accede to increased autonomy, especially in the area of food and water, those are the basics. Haitians already have a relatively solid educational system, it's just that it only teaches basic literacy dominated by religious values.

The desire to do good is on of the greatest tools for manipulation of the masses in propaganda.

Like Jaume said you can't know. Usually a good way to know whether you are being manipulated is when you suddenly realize that you feel very strongly about a place you only have a vague idea about where you could find it without typing it into the search-box in Google Earth.

The desire to do good is on of the greatest tools for manipulation of the masses in propaganda.

 

And "the road to Hell is paved with good intentions."

Another is when you are convinced you're being put in immediate existential danger by a small, sparsely populated island somewhere in the Caribbean without really being able to explain why.

 

No, we should not be involved in other countries wars. We should mind our own business. Even if we asked to interfere we shouldn't.
Saudi oil is the US's business. Containing China's aggressive economic policies is the US's business. Stability in developing countries for the sake of, well, Big Business, is the US's business. It won't be easy to shake the mindset that every place in the world but my toilet (and I'm not even sure about that), is the US's business.
Yep (even my toilet. ) Globalization meant a lot of things a while back, but the only thing that's been actually globalized today is business.

RSS

© 2013   Created by Morgan Matthew.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service