Tinker observes that Dawkins has all the hallmarks of fundamentalist religion:
  • Vehemence
  • Narrow-mindedness
  • Intolerance
Is he basically just being a .. well a" fundamentalist scientist"?

I was just interested in people views... 



Tags: atheist, dawkins, fundamentalist

Views: 47

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Vehemence is a strange choice. He's very mildly spoken, even if impassioned. I'm generally the same. Perhaps slightly louder.

He's not at all narrow-minded.

And he's certainly not intolerant.

Narrow-mindedness won't work in science. Basically you have to follow the evidence. Since there is no evidence for a magical sky man, it's pointless and naive to consider the existence of one. You may as well believe in a whole host of deities or mythical creatures.

I'm not sure about what he is intolerant. Unfortunately religion permeates itself in such a vile way throughout society that much of the dogma should not be tolerated. There's certainly never any cries to be tolerant to other sorts of dangerous beliefs.
"Dawkins is a fundie" roflmfho!!! That's the funniest thing I have EVER heard!
Sadly, you will hear that a lot from religionists and accommodationists.
Very well put!

I think the issue of intolerance here is really an issue of "well founded intolerance". If someone told me my skin was black I'd intolerant because I can see it's not!
Well said, Adriana. Thanks for saving me the time of responding!
Wait! But you just responded to say thanks for saving you the time of responding... which took the same amount of time......?
No, no. It was much easier, I assure you! ;)
Tolerance must not be confused with acceptance of falsehoods. If somebody tells me the Earth is 6000 years old, I'm not being "intolerant" by expressing an absolute refusal to believe that crap, I'm not being narrow-minded either.

Very well said, Adriana. How can refusal to accept a proven falsehood be considered "intolerant?" It just doesn't make any sense. Or, at the very least, it completely perverts any meaning of the word "intolerant."
I honestly can't think of a post by Adriana for which I disagree.

I know, me too. We must be drinking the Adriana Kool-Aid.
But it's ok because it's smart Kool-Aid. Speaking of which, pass the pitcher!
Smart and classy!

Just so you know, Shine, good wine is not served in a pitcher. It comes in a box. :p
Dawkins is over rated, and a lot of atheist seem to have a "cult of personality" of dawkins.


© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service