Life is full of changes. My wife and I just received custody of her 13 year old grand-daughter. So now we are a family of three. I have already been warned about expressing my "lack of belief" toward her. This child has been going to church, Sunday school, etc for awhile. Of course all that will stop at this point as my wife is a non-participating Catholic and I haven't been INSIDE a church in eons.


Should I respect my wife's wishes and stay mute or wait for an opportunity to provide "the rest of the story?"



Views: 51

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I don't see the harm in being honest with your new family addition especially since she's 13 especially if she is asking questions or starts asking questions. She's 13 she's not really a kid anymore, she deserves to hear the truth about your beliefs or lack there of and I think it's good for all children to know that there is more than one option out there in terms of beliefs or lack there of. In the end she will be her own person now is the prime time to allow her a safe place to explore and experiment with her own thoughts on religion and beyond. I wish I'd had someone to at least let me know that other options were out there... I gave up on god at 9 but spent years thinking that there was something wrong with me because I was never even so much as informed there were alternatives.

One of my biggest fears is that my husband and I will die and relatives will be ready to comfort him with heaven and god.  


I don't know what has happened that this girl is now living with her grandmother and step-grandfather, but I imagine it is a huge adjustment for all three of you.  I would respect your wife's wishes and not say anything overtly.  If this girl's life has been hard or if she lost her parents suddenly, shaking her faith right now may do more harm than good.  If she's living with you, she'll get a feel for your ideas on her own.  She'll notice you don't say grace before meals, she'll notice a lack of religious icons or artwork, she'll notice you never go to church.  If she asks, be honest, but gentle.  Refuse to participate in her church or religious observances, but give her space to come to terms with her new situation in life. Maybe after she's settled in a little and has started to deal with the things that led her here, she'll be able to have a conversation about your non-faith and your wife's non-practicing Catholicism.  

I think it is important that you be honest with her. If she asks why you do not go to church, tell her. If she asks why you do not believe, tell her. Being upfront and straightforward about your lack of belief and about what you do believe is the best bet, in my opinion.

With regard to your wife's request, does she really want you to lie or just 'no comment' anytime the subject is broached?

Wait for the opportunity. I have a 3 year old foster son who's grandmother is very religious. He's already using their "language". I'm Atheist and my partner is Agnostic (his aunt). I hid his religious children's books in his dresser. Oh petty is that? lol I got tired of him selecting them for reading time before bed. After reading the very graphic Daniel in the Lion's Den I had enough. My partner suggest I wait for him to to start asking questions. Because he definitely will when he realizes that our home is very different from his Nana's. We don't pray before we eat. We don't go to church. We don't talk about god, Jesus, angels or demons. He goes to church with her twice a week and they pray before eating every single time.

In the meantime I get myself ready by buying science books for kids his age and teaching him that the fiction books we read are just stories. I include art, music, dancing, history, science, math in our playtime. As he grows intellectually he will understand or at least have knowledge of how I understand the world. If he asks me a question I will not lie. I will try to explain things in a way to not make his Nana look crazy even though i believe she is. That is when sociology comes in. Teach him the way of the world.


So be patient and be ready.

Wait for the right opportunity, and then find the connection, and go from there.  It's not a natural family situation for you to be muted.  But at the same time, don't expect any comments to lead to any quick changes.


My son is living with his mother.  I'm atheist.  He's being raised religious.  But now every time I pick him up, he gets into the car, and the first thing he says is "So!  What science topic should we talk about?"


It's taken a year and a half to get to this point.  And actually, our discussions started in the reverse -- I abruptly denied god, rather than using science as the in.  He had commented something about how god was bringing in some rain.  I could tell that came, almost as a literal quote, from the other side of the family.  The absurdity got to me.  Before I could censor myself, I told him that I don't believe god exists, and launched into the actual scientific explanations of weather.  That has worked out well, because he tends toward math and science.


So find the connection.  That's simply part of being a parent.

Wait for an opportunity and give some hints here and there. Also, let him choose. Wait until he is capable of thinking for himself.

I have the same issue with my 14 year old son. His mother is very religious and and I'm allergic to religion :) The best way to handle it (or just about anything) is to be honest with her. Wait until she asks you questions (and she will) and then give her honest answers. You really can't go wrong that way. No one can say anything to you or has any right to disrespect your honesty, especially if you waited for her to ask and you simply let your daughter decide for herself what she wants to do with your honest answers.

My son is still a believer but knows full well I am not and why. His mother has never said anything because she knows no reasonable person in the world can except you to lie, especially to your own children.

Good luck.! and congratulations on custody, I'm very happy for you!

Thanks Everyone for the sound advice. I will let time take it's course and offer her explanations as she becomes more curious.

I just hope this doesn't create friction between my spouse and I. Maybe it can be a secret conversation......  :^ )



Rather than say what your beliefs are (or are not) give your view as another perspective to be considered. All you need to do is talk about her giving consideration to all sides but that she must make her own decisions. If she learns to reason and develop her critical thinking abilities she will come to the sensible conclusion. Teenagers like to make there own decisions. Yeah, like right, Whatever :)

I have a good pdf on the subject – Raising Freethinkers – if you (or anyone else) want a copy just email me with RF in the title.
The story is all around us. Start there.
It sounds as though the girl is the grand-daughter of your wife, so I am assuming that she is your step-grand-daughter.  My advice is if you want a happy marriage, keep your mouth shut.  If the girl asks you directly, simply say that her grandmother has asked you not to talk about your beliefs.  If she asks why, direct her to her grandmother.  Eventually something will have to give, but if you make the effort to respect your wife's wishes then at least you can't be blamed.  Even so, be prepared to be blamed.
Just figure out what she likes to read and let her have it, if she like biology let her read books on biology, or if she likes koran let her read the koran everything about koran including the bloody history and let her make up her mind.


© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service