So I am having an exchange with a Christian:

Xtian: Doesn't this ruin the theory of billions of years - http://www.redorbit.com/news/science/1112719213/protein-preservatio...

Me: What are you on about?

Xtian: If evolution is true, these dinosaur bones should be millions of years old, therefore it is impossible that any organic materials should be found in the fossils.

Me: "The study findings...solidify the case for the preservation of cells and possibly DNA in ancient remains." - the bones are still millions of years old, you're just making a false assumption saying it's impossible for organic materials to survive for millions of years."“The data thus far seem to support the theory that these structures can be preserved over time,” Schweitzer says. “Hopefully these findings will give us greater insight into the processes of evolutionary change.”"

Xtian: Well evolutionists have said that it is impossible for a while and many have been denying these claims of dinosaur cells, up until now that there is overwhelming evidence.
Where are the links in evolutionary chains anyway. There have been a few cases where they thought they found connections in the chain. All of them so far have turned out to be either a mixture of different species bones put together or a known creature which was deformed or disabled. You can hardly call that science.
My point is that I don't care if people believe in evolution, but don't call it a science, when it is more like a religion.

 

 


So what are the thoughts on my reply!?

 

Tags: christian, darwin, evolution, fossils, xtian

Views: 116

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

   I suppose that a case could be made that evolution is a religion if it is a belief blindly held by uneducated, ignorant people.  But for those who have actually studied, experimented, and tested the theory empirically, it is NOT religion, it is solid, unimpeachable SCIENCE.  Evolution HAPPENED.  It has ALWAYS happened.  It IS happening now.  It always WILL happen.  It MUST happen.  It cannot NOT happen.  Life and evolution are inextricably linked as a single process.  If and when evolution comes to and end, so, too, will all life.  Life IS evolution.

There have been a few cases where they thought they found connections in the chain. All of them so far have turned out to be either a mixture of different species bones put together or a known creature which was deformed or disabled. You can hardly call that science.

Your reply seems fine, but this person is talking out their ass a bit too much to really correct. By 'correct' I don't mean that he needs to accept evolution, but rather that his claims are not correct. This may be overly judgmental, but when someone clings to such marginal claims without a) providing sources, or b) acknowledging numerous of examples to the contrary, you have to wonder if they sincerely oppose evolutionary theory, or if they are just looking for any convenient excuse not to have to deal with it.

But I will note that there is at least one famous case of a 'mixture of bones': the Piltdown Man hoax. Why do creationists think this proves a point? Do you know what debunked Piltdown Man? God? Prayer? The Bible? No, of course not. It was rational skepticism and scientific investigation. Why does this person cling to science when they think it scores a point for their view, yet feels free to dismiss science willy-nilly when it contradicts their views? If it was a matter of pointing out internal inconsistencies  that would be one thing, but frankly this just seems like bias.

/rant

RSS

Religion Virus

Forum

Representing.....fetuses?

Started by Belle Rose in Law, Trials, and Decisions. Last reply by Jim 22 minutes ago. 5 Replies

The Good guy with a Gun is a myth.

Started by Davis Goodman in Small Talk. Last reply by Ed 46 minutes ago. 5 Replies

My Life As A College Student.

Started by Ari in Small Talk. Last reply by Reg The Fronkey Farmer 3 hours ago. 5 Replies

The Doctor and the Farmer

Started by Reg The Fronkey Farmer in Religion and the Religious, Atheism and Atheists. Last reply by Davis Goodman 6 hours ago. 403 Replies

God spoils Awe, Mystery, and Wonder.

Started by Ari in Small Talk. Last reply by Davis Goodman 7 hours ago. 6 Replies

Services we love!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service