This is not a particularly deep thread, but it seems to me that the prevalence of 'Atheism' with a capital 'A' is growing. 'Atheism' is a common noun, not a proper noun, so in English it should not normally be capitalized (unless it is at the beginning of a sentence). However, for a time I used to hear people referring to 'Big A Atheism' implying additional values ascribed to the term beyond mere lack of belief.

For those who capitalize, is this just just an odd typing habit, or are you implying something by writing 'Atheism' instead of 'atheism'? If the latter, what is your intended meaning?

For the record, I doesn't matter to me that people use one over the other; it's just a point of curiosity as to why. Personally, I prefer it as a common noun indicating nothing more than one very simple statement of disbelief in deities.

Views: 1045

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Are you suggesting that capitalising the name of a group is more about respect? Because if so I have to point out that respect is nothing to do with it.  It is an issue of grammar and only grammar 

Honestly Kris this is such an interesting question.  I had to work out when I actually capitalise and when I don't.  Is it a noun or a proper noun?  I think if I'm comparing atheism to a specific religion, like Islam or Christianity, I capitalise Atheism too.  But if I'm referring generally to atheists, I don't (except I probably have in some post or another).  I don't seem to have the same dichotomy with 'theism', however, which I don't appear to have the urge to capitalise.  How odd.

I think I'll make a personal grammar rule now, and lose the capitalisation. 

 

 I started off using a capital but I would get pulled up for it in forums..  I dont seem to have a rhythm for the word yet. Im beginning to use lower case now but I alaway have to stop & think about it.

I will often capitalize the “A” especially if I am implying the philosophy of life that ensues from being an Atheist rather than just “atheism” as a lack of belief in “gods”. Strictly speaking I am aware of the grammatical offence but I will overlook it in this case even if sometimes poor grammar is a bugbear of mine. I am conscious of doing it and even make an effort to do so in posts where I use word “god”. I even have a red “A” tattooed on my upper arm.

 

@Reg

"grammar is a bugbear of mine."

Oh No .. My grama must bug yo a lit then *% ...

No really - I get gramma anxiety around you peopl ...

See

 

Capitalizing Atheism will just feed into those theists who want to say "See, Atheism is just another religion."

I capitalize the word "Atheist" when I am referring to myself.

I agree it should probably be "atheism" and "atheists" or "atheist"

But I will settle for just getting people to form the plural properly; I still see the occasional "why are atheist [sic] doing X" type of sentence even though the worst violator got his sorry ass banned (for other reasons) months ago.

I capitalize Atheism as a sort of protest because I detest the fact that Christians have taken the English word for deity and made us capitalize it - I do not capitalize the word 'god' because I do not consider it a proper noun.

Of course their claim is that when you talk about pagan gods, you use "gods" but "God" is a synonym for Yahweh.  It's a reverse of the way some brand name becomes synonymous with the general class of product, such as "kleenex: (to mean paper tissue for the schnozz, regardless of brand) or "xerox" as a verb to mean photocopy.  People even drop the capitalization when doing this so the reversal is even more precise.

Instead of taking a specific word and applying it to a general class of thing, they've taken the general name and capitalized it and applied it to theirs.  If they did the former (treating doG like Kleenex) we might see sentences such as "Yahweh is the one true yahweh, all other yahwehs like the Greek yahwehs are false.  I worship Yahweh." (Note I capitalized the specific but not the general.)  And if we did the latter (treating facial tissues like we mistreat doG) , we'd see people talking about a box of "I want genuine name-brand Facial Tissue, not just any old facial tissue like Puffs."

My means of fighting back against this are a little more direct than yours, Heather; rather than trying to get revenge in a tit-for-tat way, I simply refuse to capitalize "god" in my every day writing (though I perforce had to do so for this discussion), unless I spell it doG or I use a construction like "thank noGod I got my taxes done."

I won't capitalize it either - but more importantly, I refuse to refer to their god using the word 'god' as a name.  Christians often claim that 'god' is the name of their god, but it is not.  If it were, then the name would be the same in every language - not translated into every language as that language's word for 'god'.  I typically use 'Yahweh/Jesus/Spirit' as the name of their gods.

I don't have a problem with you naming your dog 'Dog' either - and I would call your dog 'Dog' gladly and capitalize his name when writing it.  My problem is when you expect me to call your dog 'Chien' when I'm speaking French, 'Perro' when speaking Spanish, 'Kutya' when speaking Hungarian, etc, etc, etc.

If you expect me to use the word for dog in every single language as the name of your dog when speaking that language, then you have NOT named your dog 'Dog' - you've tried to usurp a universal meaning and I won't pander to such bullshit.  It's not about conferring/abrogating respect - it's just a matter of enforcing clear language to represent clear thoughts.  Christians have never named their god 'God', their gods are named Jesus, Yahweh, and Holy Spirit.

RSS

Forum

Dr. Oz finally getting his due

Started by Unseen in Small Talk. Last reply by Davis Goodman 13 hours ago. 4 Replies

Wicca

Started by Unseen in Religion and the Religious, Atheism and Atheists. Last reply by Belle Rose 13 hours ago. 14 Replies

Books to read in 2015

Started by Belle Rose in Advice. Last reply by Reg The Fronkey Farmer 18 hours ago. 8 Replies

Skepticon (Or Other Atheist Type of Events)

Started by Peter in Small Talk. Last reply by Belle Rose 13 hours ago. 1 Reply

Events

Blog Posts

It's all Greek to me

Posted by Simon Mathews on April 15, 2015 at 4:14am 15 Comments

Free at last

Posted by Belle Rose on April 15, 2015 at 1:00am 2 Comments

Services we love!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service