walk me through the answers of these questions plz:

1-how did the first male and female human beings appeared?

2-is there moses, jesus, mohammed _peace be upon him_??

3-why are we on earth ? what is the purpose of living??

Views: 2380

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

1-whaere did the hominid came from??

2- so you are saying that there is actually moses , jesus , mohammed _peace be upon them_ but they are not prophets they just said good stuff do this do that don't do that and so on ,, but have you asked your self what if things they said were the right thing to do ? and if they are why not read their books see if they're actually true if they were man written or came from a higher someone?

3-what if i were to tell you that there is a verse in qur'an that says :" you were only created just to know" knowledge meant in this verse knowing allah and what he created and looking around you all the time thinking and asking questions till you find the truth and it's never agains the holy qura'n , if you ever had the time try to start reading qura'n and you 'll fin it's a book that is based entirely on logic god asks you many timed to think in what is written and see if it goes with your mind or not ,,

Others have seemed to answer your questions.

My response:

1. it's all part of a long evolutionary process from earlier living mammals.

2. I assumed they lived, not as prophets per se, but they were written as to be prophets. I think of Moses more as part of a mythical story the priests found effective to explain the laws they supported; 

3. Your thinking is all based on "God" or Allah communicating with humans and explaining things to them. I really can't understand believing in a "personal god" who directly communicates with people. To me, this is part of a very ego-centric way of thinking that people and religious cultures have. It is true that we can't explain all the things in the universe, but to fall into the line of thinking that it is a god that has created all this and requires people to pray and follow "his" rules and "words" is a weakness of our species. Those rules and words were written by men in an effort to control behaviours, which at the time, were considered beneficial to the society or culture. That is all. God was given the credit for the rules and words because the superstitious were more likely to follow along if they came from a "higher" authority.

So to me, I see no logic in believing in a god at all. And, I see you as someone who has not evolved that far yet.

where did the mammals come from the first step in all the evolutionary ladder where did it come from ?

@doubtful - I've already answered this one for you in another reply, but I'll pull that answer over here for your benefit....

The evolution of mammals has passed through many stages since the first appearance of their synapsid ancestors in the late Carboniferous period. By the mid-Triassic, there were many synapsid species that looked like mammals. The lineage leading to today's mammals split up in the Jurassic; synapsids from this period include Dryolestes, more closely related to extant placentals and marsupials than to monotremes, as well as Ambondro, more closely related to monotremes.[1] Later on, the eutherian and metatherian lineages separated; the metatherians are the animals more closely related to the marsupials while the eutherians are those more closely related to the placentals. Since Juramaia, the earliest known eutherian, lived 160 million years ago in the Jurassic, this divergence must have occurred in the same period. After the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event wiped out the non-avian dinosaurs (birds are generally regarded as the surviving dinosaurs) and several other mammalian groups, placental and marsupial mammals diversified into many new forms and ecological niches throughout the Paleogene and Neogene, by the end of which all modern orders had appeared.

Mammals are the only living synapsids.[2] The synapsid lineage became distinct from thesauropsid lineage in the late Carboniferous period, between 320 and 315 million years ago.[3] The sauropsids are today's reptiles and birds along with all the extinct animals more closely related to them than to mammals.[3] (This does not include the mammal-like reptiles, a group more closely related to the mammals.)

RE: "where did the mammals come from the first step in all the evolutionary ladder where did it come from ?"

Read Richard Dawkins' book, The Ancestor's Tale, it will answer your question better than any of us can. When you've finished, get back to us and let us know what you've learned. Off you go now --


It appears to me from the questions you keep asking here that you are not reading the answers you have been given or you have read but just refused to internalize them. Take same time and do us a favour, read and internalize then ask your next group of questions.

Clark, said he assumed, that doesn't mean he took them to be true if I get the statement correctly. That aside, unless you don't venture out of the quran which I think is the case here, you would have discovered there is a big body of research on the historicity of your [sic]holy prophets that you should spend time reading before you make such outrageous claims here! Besides if you can lay your hand on any extra quranic evidence of mohammed, this does not include hadiths, present them here. You have a desire to believe in some higher being, something that we here can't stop you from, so don't sell it to us.

Now that you have told us so what? Do you understand logic to tell us the quran is based on logic? but if it is, how does that make it special? Aristotles treatise are based on logic and I don't see or hear anyone claiming they are the works of a fairy! You have chosen a life of servitude to an imaginary sky god, I can't free you from that even if I tried!

In conclusion, what would you make of your god, why does he chose just your prophet and not the guy next door? Don't you think it would make this business of religion easier if he periodically appeared to everyone at the same time and came to update his books so they are not outdated? Still on the same question, how is it that in all this epiphanies of your god, he didn't get to China, or was China too far for him to get there?

Populations change very very slowly. There never was a first human. Was there a moment when you went from toddler to adult? Here have a look at this.

http://i.imgur.com/xWpvw.jpg for another way of illustrating the point.

"What was the first purple word in the block of text above?"

Obviously the world purple. DUH. Give me a harder one next time!

1-There was no first man or woman.  I would explain evolution to you, but I suspect I would be whistling into the wind.

2-There was no Moses or Jesus for peace to be upon.  Mohammed, I don't know.

3-Life has no purpose.  But if you insist on thinking there must be one, then what is the purpose of dying? 

all i'm asking where did the first step in the evolution came from ??

@doubtful - the first step in evolution would have been the first occurrence of speciation.  I thought you were a 'octor' - I thought octors would be aware of these things.


© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service