Hi All,

We had a discussion many moons ago about atheists and morality and a lot has happened since then. I reached some new conclusions (which I'll withhold for now so I don't poison the water) and at least one other poster here has some new ideas about it.

So, I was wondering what the prevailing opinion is out there on this topic. Do you believe that atheists can be "moral"? Is it impossible for an atheist to be truly moral? Is "morality" something to which adherents have a valid claim? The infamous Dawkins and Harris had a discussion at Oxford about this about a year or so ago that was very good and I would also be interested in what anyone thinks of what was discussed there.

Thanks and all are welcome.

- kk

Views: 1648

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That's the trick.  Multiple points between the poles could be equally valid, all depending on what 'blend of balance' is subjectively appealing.  Multiple behaviors could also be equally valid on a given point.  That gives a wide range of behaviors that could be considered moral (or immoral).

All part of the argument as to why morality is subjective.  It is easy to find agreement on morality at the poles, but much harder among the subtle grades closer to center.

Hey Obfuskation,

So, does this mean that we can't find an objective rule to apply for those gray areas inbetween? I think that's what you are saying, right?

Second, unrelated question: As for the poles, can you ever be sure you've correctly identified a pole? In other words, can you ever be sure that your "extreme" is actually the most "extreme" possibility?

- kk

I think it would be possible to find an objective method to weigh actions in respect to moral values, but the establishment and scaling of values would be very subjective between cultures and individuals.

I think that the most extreme ends would probably be the realm of mental illness.  Probably psychopathy at one end, and some type of martyrdom complex at the other.  That's off the top of my head; I haven't put much thought into stretching the poles to extremes, and I'm doing hit and run posts from work.  :)

Hey Obfuskation,

No worries, yea, this makes sense. So, if anyone were to come up with an extreme, regardless of how good of a job they did, would you be confident that this is an ulitmate extreme, or extreme for which there can never be found one to exceed it? I'm asking because this gets at Sam's point.

- kk

I can't say one way or the other.  Like I said, I haven't put a lot of thought into this area.

Let me get this straight.  You expect me to pass judgment on the state of my own morality?  

Hey Dale,

Ha, well, not exactly. I was just asking if you think an atheist can be moral. And if so, how?

- kk

Hi all,

Okay, so this is the second part I was holding back until I got some opinions to work with. My conclusion after looking at it for a while was that:

Morality is public myth.

I concluded that there is in fact no such thing as "morality" and that this was something created or promoted to global awareness through religion. It is a testament to how effective the propaganda of religion can be.

This poses a big problem for atheists because we are in the unenviable position of having to defend our "morals" when we (or lets say just I) know that morality is a myth anyway. And how do you explain that to an adherent? This is just one more example of how powerful the clutches of religion really are. The influence of religion has infected everything, from "morality" to sexuality (which is not a myth), and virtually every atheist still buys into it.

I'll share my rationale as we discuss

- kk

Hey - thx - kk

I would have to disagree that morality is a myth.  I look at it more as an instinctive framework with wide variables.  The impulses arise naturally, but are personally codified through experience and/or indoctrination.

I would also disagree that morality was created or promoted into awareness by religion.  I would say that it was hi-jacked, and rigid moral ideologies were created and propagated by religion.

The great thing about morality and it's origins is that it seems to be the current main battleground in the theist/atheist discussion.  It's a discussion where atheists hold an advantage, because we are not encumbered by the savage immorality within 'holy' books the way theists are.

Hey Obfuskation,

I would have to disagree that morality is a myth.  I look at it more as an instinctive framework with wide variables.  The impulses arise naturally, but are personally codified through experience and/or indoctrination.

My rationale for this is that:

Morality cannot exist practicably speaking as there is no
way to operationally define it. It cannot be operationally defined because we
cannot be certain that any two arbitrarily selected individuals will agree as
to what is “moral”. Therefore, morality can never be made objective. This was
never a possibility, though so many have tried. If it cannot be made objective
then we cannot operationally define it, ironically, by definition. An
operational definition is one that all observers can observe to be one and the
same because they act operationally upon the assumption of its definition for a
common purpose. Without this condition, any operational definition of morality would
be internally inconsistent.

Thus, anyone speaking of morality is speaking of myth, imo.

- kk

I should probably clarify that my disagreement is based on the wording of your claim.

Morality is simply standards of behavior that are seen as right or wrong.  There is an abundance of moral codes in the world, with understandable variances between cultures.

If your claim is that an objective moral code is a myth, then I would tend to be in agreement.



hebrew bullshit

Started by seamus mc ardle in Small Talk. Last reply by Reg The Fronkey Farmer yesterday. 6 Replies

Does Human Nature Change?

Started by Tom Sarbeck in Philosophy. Last reply by Davis Goodman 2 hours ago. 14 Replies

Blog Posts

The First Lie

Posted by Andrew Brown on April 24, 2017 at 12:46pm 4 Comments

13 April

Posted by Noon Alif on April 24, 2017 at 7:08am 0 Comments

© 2017   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service