I'm sure we've all dealt with theists debating with us that communist nations such as North Korea are atheist nations and in their view that atheism can be just as fundamentalist as religion.
But what is the reality here? Does communism and atheism have a connection? Or is the communism in North Korea promoted due to some other reason? Or do both sides really have their good and bad sides and we as a species generalise far too much?
Thank you. Yes i would tend to agree with that. I actually recall an excellent interview with Dawkins where he basically defines communism and marxism as State Religions
Yes. I saw that. Disappointing.
I don't care if communist nations are atheist or not. Not accepting religious idiocy has nothing to do with advocating a communist political philosophy. The most atheistic societies today are in Scandanavia and Japan, and they have shown no proclivity towards communism. Communist countries have oppressed religion for their own nefarious ends, just as many Western nations have exploited religion for nefarious ends. I think the sane-thinking people of the world agree that modern social democracies that ensure human rights and balance economic freedom with regulation are the best idea we've come up with to promote human flourishing. This necessarily includes both the separation of church and state and the protection of religious freedom. It is better for atheists and theists alike.
is the communism in North Korea promoted due to some other reason?
North Korea is commonly associated with being bad. If North Korea were an Atheist bastian of rationality and reason, it wouldn't be mentioned at all imo.
Communism, capitalism and socialism are economic models defined by ownership..
Under communism, resources that are important to the community well being are owned by the community, maintained by the community and shared by the community, often in a not for profit mode.
Communism is not anti business. Business models based in communist theory include Co-ops, Credit unions, mutual insurance companies and volunteer fire brigades
Communism is not anti religion. In fact, many Christian communities are based on communist principles. The Amish and Mennonite communities in the US and many of the kibbutzim in Israel value the collectivism and cooperative effort fundamental to communism.
Communism does not scale to a national level. This is due to cultural fragmentation. Most so-called communist national governments are based on Marxism, a philosophy that using heavy handed methods to minimize and subdue regional differences through mandated uniformity. Marxism forbids religion, as it recognizes religious institutions as competing governmental systems.
Most Marxist governments arise in nations with a large agrarian population
Hi Keith, there was a couple of quotes from the recent Olympics... when the American's won a gold medal, they would thank God or Jesus... when the North Korean's won a gold medal, they thanked their glorious leader.
What level of brain washing would induce that? Religious indoctrination. The North Korean heads of state abolished existing religion to replace it with a religion idolising the leader.
Furthermore, neither atheism now communism state in their ideologies (or lack thereof) anything about the other.