I'm in the midst of a religious debate with a Christian who claims that the following phrase is NOT religious:

I claimed that opposition to birth control is PURELY religious.  He claimed that he could conceive of an atheist who believed that "every possible human being had a right to exist and we had no right to block the chance" and would therefore oppose birth control for reasons that are NOT religious.

Opinions?

Views: 342

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That was my first response to him!  Pretty much along the lines of, "You've already shown that you have no problem conceiving of a giant telekinetic invisible humanoid that rules the world..."

I didn't think they existed either, but they do.

However, I will note that he was only against pills, IUD's, emergency contraception, implants, patches, and any forms that allow possible fertilization of an egg but not implantation. An atheist can certainly believe that personhood begins at conception and fertilized eggs deserve all basic rights to exist therefore most birth control = murder.

While I'm sure most atheists would fall into the so-called pro-choice camp, the two topics are totally disconnected. There is nothing about opposing abortion that is inconsistent with a lack of belief in a theistic deity.

The question was whether or not an atheist could believe that a potential human had the right to exist and would oppose birth control for non religious reasons. The answer is yes and one non-religious reason is strong opposition to abortive methods of birth control. How exactly are those two topics disconnected?

I was saying only that being an atheist doesn't necessarily imply a position one way or the other on abortion, which is a totally different question. Similarly, not all theists are opposed to abortion. There is the disconnection.

Your responses seem to imply that I claimed opposition to abortion is inconsistent with atheism when I actually stated the opposite as a logical reason why an atheist might oppose birth control. I also cited an example of one such atheist on this very site to answer to the title question of this post.

I didn't claim being an atheist or theist necessarily implies a position one way or another on abortion.

No fighting you two!  I'll turn this thread right around!

I repeat: I was saying only that being an atheist doesn't necessarily imply a position one way or the other on abortion, which is a totally different question. Similarly, not all theists are opposed to abortion. There is the disconnection.

We don't disagree.

RSS

Forum

An Atheist Time Capsule

Started by Belle Rose in Small Talk 7 hours ago. 0 Replies

9 dead, 46 wounded by gunfire in Chicago

Started by Unseen in Society. Last reply by matt.clerke 1 hour ago. 7 Replies

Questions from an old member who hasn't been around in quite awhile...

Started by Rocky Oliver (LotusGeek) in Small Talk. Last reply by Rocky Oliver (LotusGeek) 16 hours ago. 3 Replies

New site

Started by umar in Announcements. Last reply by Kamel zebib 1 hour ago. 56 Replies

Events

Blog Posts

My Purity Ring

Posted by Michelle Varni on July 5, 2015 at 7:18pm 5 Comments

Services we love!

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2015   Created by umar.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service