As of now, only Oregon and Washington have assisted suicide laws. Given that Oregon had one first, and then Washington followed suit, that may be the way it spreads: from state to neighboring state. Why? Because it's easier to see that it's working in an adjoining state. Also, adjoining states often have similar cultural values.

What are your views? Anyone here actually against assisted suicide or have grave doubts about it? 


Views: 581

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Assisted or not, I don't have a problem with anyone choosing to quit this life. Should you need help, you could arrange for me a return ticket, I will not disappoint you :-P

Can I help?  I will hold his hand and say encouraging mystical  sounding words. :)

Can we burn some incense?

I like sandalwood.

Incense is a good idea, do you have matches?

No, but I got two sticks. :)

No. We have no say in the matter if someone wants to die but is unable to administer their own death. It is utter discrimination against those who are unable to commit suicide that they must live and suffer while those who can buy pills and swallow them can end their misery whenever they want. My only concern is for the person who passes them the tool of death and that they be emotionally prepared for what they are going to do and be realistically able to deal with it afterwards.

...and sheltered from unintended legal consequences of assisting.

Yes...and that too!

I'm pro assisted suicide, and against enforced death penalty. It think it would be more humane to allow the convicted person to choose, life in max security prison, without parole or death by preferred method. I say preferred method, because I'm afraid of needles. So If I were on Death Row, I'd like to choose my method. I'd probably go with firing squad, or guillotine. Large caliber bullet to the back of the head, while blindfolded, it's likely that you wont feel a thing, or at least not long enough for it to matter. Guillotine, they can apply a topical anesthetic if you're that nervous, but a 1/4" thick, razor sharp blade that weighs upward to 100 lbs, you won't feel anything at all.

I bring up the death penalty, because it could be bundled with Assisted suicide, and we could make it all about freedom of choice. You don't have the right to end someone else's life, but you have the right to end your own, choose how to do it, and ask someone to help you.

Suppose that, given the death penalty, someone who murders someone HAS chosen suicide, at least as the possible outcome of their choice. 

Giving the murderer a choice of how to die would offend many who remember that the victim wasn't given that choice.

Not necessarily. They get to choose between a 4/6 foot cell, or nonexistence. To be honest, I think those who are pro death penalty don't believe actually punishing murder. Punishment implies the opportunity to learn from the punishment. Death is a way out. Sure it's a scary way out, but since there's no hell or heaven, then what are they learning?

I believe in prisoner rehabilitation, rather than criminal education. Many people who kill someone are actually regretful and, for lack of a better term, repentful. They can be reintegrated into society. What's the point in being an atheist if we aren't receptive to allowing people to learn from their mistakes.

Let me offer the arguments of the opposition.

Many would say that the death penalty isn't about murder that was done, it's about preventing more murders. Many a convicted murderer, upon being released murders again. Even in prison, murderers might murder another prisoner who's in there for a lesser crime. It happens.

Put him in solitary confinement you say? Many of the same people who oppose capital punishment are actively arguing that solitary confinement is cruel and unconstitutional.

Punishment isn't always administered with rehabilitation in mind. It may be done with simple "eye for an eye" justice in mind, and to provide a modicum of satisfaction for the living victims of the murderer, who lost a loved one forever.

To be done properly, releasing a murderer based the suspicion they might have been rehabilitated would require a crystal ball or time machine.


© 2019   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service