Hello members of Think Atheist.  I am about to post a comment I made in the 'The black people' discussion.  


It is as follows.  



"It depends on 'how' you criticize a group of people.  


It is a fact that in the USA , the highest %'s of crime is due to Blacks - and generally there is a positive correlation between the population density of blacks in large cities to an increase in crime rate.  


It is also a fact that most inner city schools are a majority Black.  They also have the lowest test scores.  


It is also a fact that most 'hip-hop' and 'rap' music on the market includes a lot of Black people cursing, and talking about doing drugs in their cars, killing cops, hittin up dem 'hoes', dropping out of school, etc. 


It is also a fact that there are many Blacks in this country who openly speak out about the Black community and criticize them ... and rightfully so.  


But this is obviously not because they are Black.  It is because of social and economic reasons.  You need to be careful how you analyze the situation - to say these symptoms are because they are 'Black' is just disgustingly ignorant.  But the fact does remain that blacks are a problem in the USA communities.  


My uneducated reason for this - is because after slavery was abolished - Black people were still either feared / hated / put down / segregated , etc ... and only in the past few decades have they started to be accepted as 'human beings' by the vast majority of whites.  


But I will say publically that they are not doing their job as a group in our country to better themselves and to make great lives for their children.  Many are too busy putting down education - getting involved in drugs - getting young teen women pregnant (or getting themselves pregnant) - and paying too much attention to popular black media that makes millions of dollars every year keeping blacks in their same positions.  


It's not cool to impregnate - be a drug dealer - talk about killing cops - breaking the law - poppin bottles in da ice like a blizzard - or using extremely vulgar language - or using a form of music lyric ebonix.  


With all that said, if evidence was put forth that white populations were in fact less intelligent - this would easily be accepted.  If it points to Blacks - riots would occur.  I personally believe that Black people as a race are stronger - bigger - more athletic compared to their white / asian counterparts.  This is easily observed.  


Why can't the IQ or intelligence also be relative?  I'm not saying it's true - I'm just saying it's a possibility - as I assume intelligence is part of the genes.  As is your height - weight - etc.  


Fire away at me - I'm sure most of you who criticize my post will have misread it thinking I'm being racist - when in fact I'm not.  


Ok, so my question is - does this comment of mine exhibit racism?

I would honestly like to know your opinions.

Just as Atheists say they are 'open' to evidence that Gods exist - so I am 100% open to discovering a certain racial group may have increased or decreased intelligence. I in no way was saying anything remotely close to implying Black people are less intelligent as a 'race'. If my comment implied this, I apologize. But I don't think it does.

I am only posting this because I believe I am being unjustly flamed by another forum member. I did not result to name calling , or flaming in any such way. I expressed an opinion , however 'racist' that opinion may be, I leave it up to the reader. But even so, I don't believe it justifies the response given by said forum member. I also apologize if posting a new discussion is improper forum etiquette , as the other discussion is a bit confusing to read, with the other poster and myself flaming / defending each others posts.

Thanks again.

Views: 248

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

"If I was a Judge, and I knew blacks had a much higher rate of repeated crime - I would use the sentences necessary."

It's a good thing you aren't.

Actually the laws themselves give higher weights to repeated offenders.  It's the system.  Blame that.  


If I was a Judge, I would follow those laws.  So I find that to be a good trait in a Judge.  


Just like if a white guy had 6 previous convictions.  I'd slam my hammer down, and get rid of him.  


Skin has nothing to do with it.  

LoL, yeah, it kind of does.  Too bad I can't edit that.  


Freudian slip?  Hmm ... 



Skin color has a lot to do with whether or not criminal charges are ever pursued in the first place.

Evidence please?  


If my brother was murdered by a white man - is he going to get a special pass and get let go because he is white?  


If my sister was raped by the flying spaghetti monster tentacles - would that thing get a special pass? 


I think you're trying to say criminal charges in relation to drugs.  As that seems to be a big motif in these discussions.  

And I already gave reasons as to why this is so. 


But he lumped together 'conviction rate' without specifying where most of those are coming from.  


I put forth statistics that speak about 'other' types of offenses and violent crimes.  


I also mentioned that as I read in some articles, the blacks are more likely to be DEALING, not just using.  I also mentioned that homicide rates are statistically higher in regards to drug relations ... meaning blacks are more likely to kill due to drug relations.  


Those 2 things combined, I don't see why it's an issue.  


Perhaps it is true blacks are easier to see when you're sitting in a Police Vehicle - bored - with nothing to do.  


But I also think there is a legitimate reason blacks get convicted more often. 



Not just drugs.  Serious, violent crime will cause the police to pursue the criminal almost regardless of race, but there is sometimes an element of racism in law enforcement even with regard to those crimes.  More important, is the fact that whites are usually sufficiently empowered in other ways and thus use different criminal activities to achieve their goals.  Whites don't hold up liquor stores; they run "hedge funds".  Whites don't commit murder; they pull the strings of power or use gossip to ruin their victim's life instead.


Based on my personal, subjective experience, whites commit as much crime as blacks but it's less dramatic and tends to be overlooked both for that reason and because the perpetrators are white. 

So now you're arguing that white people get away with their illegal acts more because they have 'support' ... really!? 


I suppose if you want to talk about merely breaking the law - I'm talking about 'Violent' crimes.  

Homicide rates , murder rates , things like attacking victims. 


I'm obviously not saying that Blacks have an 'anger gene'.  I'm saying that this is a REAL issue - and to call it 'racist' for pointing it out - seems to be in a way a form of enabling.  

"Actually the laws themselves give higher weights to repeated offenders.  It's the system.  Blame that. "

The measuring tool is broken as you should be able to see from other posts.

So the statistic that shows 50% of ALL homicides in the United States are from Blacks - is part of this ?  


Or you just talking about the 'war on drugs'?  

It doesn't show that that 50% of ALL homicides in the United States are from Blacks.

Doone posted it already as well.  It's a statistic.  


Another number I saw was 48.9% - but it all depends on what year it was.  


© 2018   Created by Rebel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service