A close-knit ultra-Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn was plunged into a new round of mourning Monday by the death of a baby who was delivered by cesarean section after his parents were killed in a grisly hit-and-run crash a day earlier.

Police hunted for the suspected driver, identified as Julio Acevedo, saying he was barreling down a residential street in a BMW at 60 mph, or twice the speed limit, on Sunday morning when he collided with a car hired to take the couple to the hospital.

The death of the newborn on Monday piled tragedy upon tragedy and compounded the community's grief. The infant was expected to be buried near the fresh graves of his parents, Nachman and Raizy Glauber, both 21. About a thousand community members turned out for the young couple's funeral a day earlier.

"The mood in the neighborhood is very heavy," said Oscar Sabel, a retired printer who lives near the scene of the accident. "We all hoped the baby would survive."

Brooklyn is home to the largest community of ultra-Orthodox Jews outside Israel, more than 250,000. The couple married last year and were living in the Williamsburg neighborhood.

They were members of the Satmar Hasidic sect, whose men dress in dark coats and hats, wear long beards like their Eastern European ancestors and have limited dealings with the outside world. Raizy Glauber grew up in a prominent rabbinical family. Her husband was studying at a rabbinical college; his family founded a line of clothing for Orthodox Jews. (source)

Question for the religious people here: If it was God's will that these parents and their unborn baby die in a hit and run, how can we hold the driver responsible based on his free will?

Tags: God's, free, will

Views: 736

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Even though this question is not intended for me to respond, being an atheist, I am anyway.

My initial reaction when I heard this news story the other day was of sadness. It's a sad experience for families and friends to go through, the death of loved ones. Reading this more detailed description here, and then reading the posed question, I recall numerous times during a funeral service or in reading a death notice, about how the event was an act of God, that the deceased is now with God, that God works in mysterious ways, or it was part of God's plan. For all of my adult life, I have been amazed that people can hold on to that religious thought at all. Due to my beliefs, with the exception of close family and friends, I will only attend visitations or wakes, not the actual funeral service.

I my mind, there may be several correct answers to the question, however who is to say what God's intent was. Maybe God had to prevent this couple from having children because of what they would have done in the future; or maybe the speeding driver needed to experience whatever is in his future as punishment for his past. Preachers and Rabbis and others could invent numerous theories. All I'll do, once again, is shake my head, roll my eyes, and/or sigh, partially amused and partially annoyed that intelligent (?) people can think and believe these things.

I think you're missing my central point which is, how can the driver have free will and be held responsible for his actions if, as religious people say, "It is God's will"?

The accident might have had multiple purposes. But it may be how God is punishing the driver, be it for some other thoughts or actions. That could be God's will. And any punishment society gives that man is God's will as well.

There are other religious people who feel God does take a step back and lets life on Earth just happen, more or less as an observer to His/Her creation. In that case, God's will is to permit bad things to happen on Earth, as many believe the only important judgement happens in Heaven.

To some people we are all just puppets of God: we have no "free will".  To others, we are servants who must do as instructed if they wish to receive the ultimate, final reward. Otherwise, we will be doomed for eternal punishment. 

Yet another contradiction to religious thinking... It is both God's will, and the driver's fault.

You just can't win, and you can't even break even!

Why  not buy into the simple, obvious answer? God is imaginary and bad things happen to everyone, good  and bad..

Well I don't believe in "God", but I was trying to take the viewpoint of religious people that I know. I believe most religious people try to find answers using a belief in a god because of their inability to comprehend a world without a supreme being, due to their indoctrination of their religion. They will interpret passages from their holy books to justify laws and decisions to deal with those whose actions go against what they believe is the lifestyle and behaviour their god wants practiced.

Most religious people cannot "buy into the simple, obvious answer". For them to even let their thoughts go too deeply there is a terrible thing. The fear factor helps keep them under control.

Better to help the family recover, and keep the ass---- off the streets.

I'll answer this one Unseen. I'm not too far removed from the Christian mindset being that I'm still and Atheist in diapers. I cannot speak for any other religions though...but I think I could sum up what many Christians might argue on this point.

The idea that God gave us free will does not take away personal responsibility and the effect of consequences. There are always consequences to our actions. There is also the universal truth that life is unfair. It is. No matter how much we WANT life to have fairness and justice it simply is not possible. When a Christian says we all have "free will" it in inherently tied to the doctrine of predestination, which is completely unrelated to life events/decisions affecting our day to day lives, including the horrible decision of some crazed maniac that ended in tragedy. It is easy to bring god into it and try to argue the Atheist position and say that god must not exist because he let so many horrible things happen. This however is a circular argument from an Atheist that goes nowhere fast. The reason for that is that the Christian also shares in the belief that what happened is tragic, but their assessment of the outcome has more to do with the eternal perspective of the "kingom of God" and who gets to enter and who doesn't. It is taught that this life is ultimately not our home so we shouldn't get too comfortable in it. Our home is with our creator after we die. Therefore, anything that happens in this life doesn't ultimately have any eternal significance other than our stance as to whether we have accepted Jesus as Lord and Savior of our lives. So the questions a Christian would be asking is, "was the driver of the car "saved?" and if not then they are burning in hell..." but that's not for US to decide, only GOD knows (sarcasm here)...It's usually assumed without question that the victims of such a tragedy are now in a "better place" because they are now with God in eternal bliss ie heaven....So while the tragedy is sad, it is easily said that justice was served, because ultimately God is in control and the innocent go to be with him....Hope that helps.

I didn't find the answer to my question in there. When a horrendous event happens resulting in loss of life, and it seems that some party is responsible, how can he (the perpetrator) be said to have free will if the accident is God's will? It seems it should be one or the other but not both.

I guess my point is that the Christian concept of free will is not applicable here. Free will is in relation to your choice as to whether you accept or reject god. Not day to day decisions. If you ask is it God's will that would depend on the Christian you ask. Some would say yes and some would say no.

Belle - "Free will is in relation to your choice as to whether you accept or reject god."  

That makes sense to me, if you define God['s love] in the right way.  Obviously, if he wasn't having a heart attack or something, but was just being careless - then Julio Acevedo chose to reject it.  Love is not an all-powerful thing, and we can accept or reject it. 

RSS

Support T|A

Think Atheist is 100% member supported

All proceeds go to keeping Think Atheist online.

Donate with Dogecoin

Members

Forum

R.I.P What Does it Mean to You?

Started by Stephen Sutton in Small Talk. Last reply by Davis Goodman 13 minutes ago. 76 Replies

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

Services we love

We are in love with our Amazon

Book Store!

Gadget Nerd? Check out Giz Gad!

Into life hacks? Check out LabMinions.com

Advertise with ThinkAtheist.com

© 2014   Created by Dan.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service