My point, which you seem at pains to miss, is that I can't base a sweeping generalization based on the behavior or attitudes of a minority. The same sort of flawed logic that allows one to draw the conclusion that "Americans are violent" can be used to conclude that "American racial minorities are violent."
It's a kind of logic which is flawed and to be avoided. I offered my argument as a reductio ad absurdum.
The Constitution is Prime Law and a living document (ie. it is changeable).
The 2nd Amendment is also Prime Law, it clearly establishes the "Right" of the "People" to own and carry weapons. The 2nd Amendment does not require a standing militia only that the power to form a militia for the defense of their "State" resides with the "People" and their privately held arms.
Those of you don't like the consequences of a Free People having a Right to own and possess guns, then follow the correct path and change the Constitution by enacting a new Amendment and having it properly ratified.
Otherwise your choice is to grin and bear it or move to Australia and hang out with Suzanne and her two dogs.
True, but in regards to a free people, property rights are paramount and as it is we don't even own the property in the US (except for parts of Texas) that the house we bought sits on. Hardly anyone has Allodial title on the land, either the "government" owns it outright or we rent it from them. Wish they would (as if they would) pass an amendment restoring allodial title rights to the common people. Hope you don't mind me changing the subject slightly.
Nah, I don't mind, change is good.
@Unseen - If I cheese somebody off with cancer say, or the flu, or diabetes, I know they are not going to kill me with said cancer, flu or diabetes.
@Gregg - Black markets will be a tad harder to find here, but it would be an interesting exercise. You would have to know where the crims hang out, then it shouldn't be too hard.
Just look for like minded people, who love their guns :)
I spent my youth walking shoulder to shoulder with those who kill the innocent, I can recognize them, they are to be feared.
#Unseen - argumentum ad ignorantiam - look at the statistics, and I will guarantee you didn't see the fabulous web page on Keep Americans Armed - http://www.americansworking.com/guns.html
or Gallup's links to statistics. All a very interesting read. Advertising and politicking at it's best.
Never mind the millions this lot make from keeping citizens frightened, as long as they make their millions. Just because you are a big, brave boy and are not frightened, doesn't mean a lot of other people are not frightened.
This is the same circular discussion with a theist, one ignores stats and deaths, one ignores the bad bits in the bible - same old, same old.
Do not care what you believe or not believe, just keep your guns over there.
@Gregg - Or grin and keep an eye out, and dodge if necessary :)
Otherwise your choice is to grin and bear it or move to Australia etc. etc.
This is exactly what the funloving christians say, if you don't Love the Lord, leave.
Here is an Aussie I want to hang out with.
Hey Suzanne, you wanna go to the range with us and blast some targets?
@Gallup - You may find this site interesting, I know Unseen and the other bloke won't read it :)
"Then it's worth posting here. ;) "
Why? Did you have difficulty clicking the link? It's the button under your finger, do you suffer from carpal tunnel syndrome?
Should I now post some BIG pro-gun poster as a counter argument to this anti-gun poster?
Or will a link do?
Just a suggestion of course.
All of the above posters have their own set of problems The first one looks like it shows a lot of cherry picking.
It's incomplete (as it admits) due to problems with data collection, but if you want to compare countries...
Also check the links at the bottom.